CivicFM
Oakland

· 6 items

Public Safety Committee, Tuesday, October 13

On the episode: Committee backs shorter parking contract extension; capital audit and housing bonds head to council

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Public Safety Committee Tuesday, October 13

6 items

The recording · Agenda

Opening announcements

Before the agenda, committee members made announcements: a commemorative bench honoring a former councilmember and police commissioner who died this past year, a City Hall resource event in East Oakland, and a recent gun-violence death in the community. 00:10:42

  • A councilmember announced that a former councilmember and police commissioner, who died this past year, will be honored with a commemorative bench on October 27, with the time to be announced by Barbara Lee (Mayor)'s office 00:10:42
  • A councilmember announced a City Hall to East Oakland event on Friday the 16th from 3:30 to 5:30, with most city departments offering resources 00:11:50
  • A councilmember noted that a community member was killed by gun violence and said the committee should each do its part to take more guns off the streets 00:12:21
  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he had sent a video to KTOP showing guns he and the police chief had recovered that he said would have ended up in East Oakland 00:12:54

Schedule of outstanding committee items Item 2

The committee's routine review of its pending list of items scheduled for future meetings. Public speakers used it to suggest topics, and members used it to praise staff for the city's exit from federal police oversight under the NSA. 00:13:32

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to approve the schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:20:27Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
  • A councilmember praised an assistant city administrator for leading the work that got the city out of the NSA 00:18:57
  • A councilmember thanked the same assistant city administrator and joked that she shouldn't answer the phone at 11 PM 00:19:26
  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he had told the Mayor in person that the assistant city administrator was doing a phenomenal job and that the city should keep her 00:19:40
  • A councilmember agreed with the praise, urged the assistant city administrator not to leave, and moved the item 00:20:16

Twice-yearly report from the Community Police Review Agency (continued) Item 3

Police oversight

A twice-yearly informational report from the Community Police Review Agency (CPRA) on its functions and duties as required by Oakland Municipal Code 2.46.030. No report was given: the director's slide presentation hadn't been attached to the agenda in writing, so the item was moved to the October 27 meeting. 00:20:27

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to continue the item to the October 27 Public Safety Committee meeting. Result: continued, 4-0. 00:24:08Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
  • A speaker said he had a slide presentation ready, but the City Attorney's office told him that day he couldn't present it because it hadn't been attached to the agenda in writing, and offered to give it aloud or reschedule 00:21:20
  • A councilmember proposed rescheduling to the next committee meeting, since the director had lost his voice, with materials due by the 17th 00:21:54
  • A speaker said he had earlier given the committee a draft of the agency's 2025 annual report and had brought copies of the final report to share 00:22:20
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked whether the annual report is available digitally and could be added to the agenda report; the reply was that it is on the agency's website and can be added 00:23:37

Police Paul Coverdell 2026 grant (withdrawn) Item 4

PolicingFederal and state funding

A police department item on the 2026 Paul Coverdell grant. The agenda says the Rules and Legislation Committee pulled it from this meeting on October 8 and placed it on the October 20 City Council consent agenda. The clerk announced this and the committee did not take it up. 00:24:08

  • No motion; the clerk announced that the Rules and Legislation Committee had withdrawn the item on October 8 and rescheduled it to the October 20 City Council consent agenda. Result: withdrawn. 00:24:08

Police firearm relinquishment grant from Alameda County Superior Court Item 5

Violence preventionPolicingFederal and state funding

A resolution to (1) ratify a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the Alameda County Superior Court, signed by a former police chief and effective December 1, 2024, and (2) accept and appropriate up to $1,563,571 in reimbursement funding under it. The money pays for equipment and staffing for a program that removes illegally held guns, guns held by people barred from having them, and guns covered by gun violence restraining orders (GVROs). Staff said the MOU was never fully executed because it needed council approval, so the department could not invoice for reimbursement until now. Staff also said the grant needs no added city spending. The agenda's history shows Rules and Legislation sent it to this special meeting on October 8 and read an urgency finding into the record. 00:25:11

▶ Hear it Is the police ceasefire section running at half strength? · 0:46

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the item to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:49:37Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Carroll Fife. From the clerk's record
  • A speaker said the money traces back to $40 million that the state Judicial Council received in 2022 for firearm relinquishment work, part of which went to the Alameda County Superior Court 00:26:01
  • A speaker said the program was meant to start in January 2025 but was pushed to July 2025 for lack of resources 00:27:01
  • A speaker explained that when the department went to invoice, it found the MOU had not been fully executed because it needed City Council approval 00:27:01
  • A speaker explained that a GVRO is a court order letting law enforcement temporarily remove guns from someone who poses a significant danger to themselves or others, and that people other than police can seek one 00:28:03
  • A speaker said 65 of Oakland's 67 homicides in 2025 involved a firearm 00:30:03
  • A speaker said the department dropped the idea of buying a technology integration platform, finding it works better to have staff connect the existing systems themselves 00:31:08
  • A speaker said the grant covers up to four sworn officers and one professional staff member already in the unit, and requires no added city spending 00:31:08
  • A speaker said the funding will be used only for GVRO work and for recovering unlawfully held guns, not for broad operations 00:32:18
  • A councilmember in a video played for the committee, described being alerted to a stash of high-impact weapons and calling James Beere (Chief, Police Department), who came right out; he said the guns were headed for District 3 or 7 00:33:30
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked staff to explain in public how the funds will be allocated and used, and what the work has accomplished so far 00:34:25
  • A speaker said part of the funding pays overtime for teams that serve GVROs and remove guns, and that much of that field work hasn't started yet because the department was waiting for the funding to be secured 00:35:22
  • A speaker said he believed 54 firearms had been recovered so far through the team's work under the initiative 00:36:24
  • A speaker said the plan is to train officers first and then build an online portal explaining how GVROs work and how to seek one 00:38:11
  • A councilmember said GVROs can be sought by family members, roommates, employers, coworkers and teachers but are underused, and asked about educating the public and training civilian police staff 00:38:59
  • A speaker said he didn't have an exact count of GVROs filed, but that usually two or three are in progress at once and each can take months 00:40:29
  • A councilmember asked about staffing in the department's Ceasefire section, saying her understanding was that it had dropped 00:41:05
  • A speaker said Ceasefire has about 16 officers, probably half or less of past levels, and that other specialized units are even lower 00:41:23
  • A councilmember asked whether the reimbursable work is something the department would be doing anyway 00:42:01
  • A speaker said the reimbursement covers a designated set of staff already in the operations center, while overtime brings in patrol or specialized officers on their days off for field work 00:44:01
  • A councilmember asked whether the grant is being billed at overtime rates rather than straight time 00:44:23
  • A speaker said the officers in the office are full-time, and that only field work, such as serving GVROs and enforcement against people barred from having guns, is done on overtime 00:44:35
  • A speaker said field operations take more resources but less time, for example ten-hour operations with six or eight officers and a sergeant 00:45:04
  • A councilmember asked whether any of the staff doing this work are civilians or whether all are sworn 00:45:41
  • A speaker said the grant reimburses one professional staff member and four sworn officers, and that an earlier plan to fully cover one civilian's salary was dropped to leave room for adding more civilian staff 00:45:54
  • A speaker answered a public speaker by saying the department never resells guns, so forfeited guns are stored and then destroyed, and that it charges no storage fees 00:48:07

Open forum

Public comment on topics not on the agenda: police equipment and racial disparities, how residents report non-emergency crimes, a community group offering to clean up San Leandro Creek, and unhoused residents asking for a voice in decisions. 00:49:37

▶ Hear it Why residents stop reporting non-emergency crimes · 0:54

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) told a speaker offering creek cleanup that the San Leandro Creek item had been at the Community and Economic Development Committee, and that Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) would be getting a briefing from the staff handling it 00:53:46
  • A councilmember said he would mention the group's work at his briefing, see whether it could get stipend money to help with the creek, and follow up with a contact 00:54:08
  • A councilmember vouched for the community group's cleanup work in District 2 00:54:26

Public comment

  • Item 2 (pending list), three speakers: one listed topics they want the committee to take up, including overcrowded housing after a fire in a 21-unit Bancroft building that held about 100 people, a Stanford report, police stop data, officer wellness after a police murder-suicide, truancy, hate-crime reporting, and the difference between militarized and protective police equipment. A second, from an unhoused people's collective, said the collective's site survived hundreds of arsons but was refused fire extinguishers, criticized how shelters are run, and said Public Works took their RV. A third praised the Mayor-led effort that ended 23 years of federal police oversight and suggested replacing NSA reports with periodic updates from the police department's risk management.
  • Item 3 (CPRA report): four people signed up; they waived their time and said they would wait for the rescheduled report.
  • Item 5 (firearm grant), one speaker: asked whether a gun owner can choose to give up a confiscated gun to be destroyed, and whether the city charges storage fees. Staff answered both.
  • Open forum, four speakers: one returned to protective versus militarized equipment and said the federal judge's final ruling found continued racial profiling of African Americans and unequal discipline of Black officers. One described community frustration that many non-emergency crimes must be reported in person to an officer, with slow response leading people not to report, and asked for a simpler reporting system; the chair said she had been thinking the same thing. One, from a community group, offered to clean up San Leandro Creek in District 7. One, from an unhoused collective, asked that unhoused residents be included in decisions about them and described being displaced again.

What's next

  • CPRA twice-yearly report (item 3) continued to the October 27, 2026 Public Safety Committee meeting; the director is to submit written materials by the 17th, and said he would submit them that day.
  • Firearm relinquishment grant resolution (item 5), up to $1,563,571, forwarded to the October 20, 2026 City Council agenda on consent.
  • Police Paul Coverdell 2026 grant (item 4) rescheduled to the October 20, 2026 City Council consent agenda.
  • Commemorative bench honoring a former councilmember and police commissioner to be installed October 27; time to be announced by Barbara Lee (Mayor)'s office.
  • Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) to get a staff briefing on the San Leandro Creek item and said he would raise the community group's offer to help.
  • Police plan to train officers on GVROs and then build an online public portal on how to seek one; no date was given.

Write to the Public Safety Committee before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error