· 6 items
Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, November 17
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Oakland's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Public Works and Transportation Committee Tuesday, November 17
6 items
Committee pending list, and a request for reports on the city's garbage contracts Item 2
Trash and recycling
The committee's routine review of its schedule of outstanding items. Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) used it to ask for informational reports on the city's contracts with Waste Management and California Waste Solutions, on Civic Corps' street cleanup work, and on how the city spends the garbage franchise fee. He said new councilmembers need that background before the contracts are negotiated. 00:11:23
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7), to approve the pending list as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:16:33Ayes: Noel Gallo, Ken Houston, Charlene Wang, Zac Unger. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Ken Houston. From the clerk's draft minutes
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) asked for a staff report on where the city stands with Waste Management and on the franchise fee Waste Management collects from ratepayers 00:13:27
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) also asked for an update on the California Waste Solutions contract and on Civic Corps trucks he sees in his district 00:13:27
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) said the new councilmembers lack the history of these contracts, and the city will be negotiating them soon 00:14:29
- A councilmember offered support in bringing the informational requests forward through the Rules Committee 00:16:06
- City staff said they would also work with him outside the meeting on the updates 00:16:14
Name change on state housing and transportation grant for 285 12th Street Item 3
Affordable housingFederal and state funding
A technical amendment to a resolution the council passed in March 2026. That resolution accepted state Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities funds for the 285 12th Street project, not to exceed $35,873,066. Staff said the state won't release the money until the resolution names the borrower by its new legal name, 285 Development LP, which is affiliated with the East Bay Asian Local Development Corporation. Staff said the award amounts and project terms don't change. The money includes a loan of about $20.4 million for affordable housing and about $14 million to the city for three nearby street projects: the 7th Street Connection, MLK Complete Streets, and the Broadway Transit Project. Staff said the site will have 65 affordable units. 00:17:01
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve the staff recommendation and forward it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:25:28Ayes: Noel Gallo, Ken Houston, Charlene Wang, Zac Unger. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff described the item as a technical amendment that changes only the legal name of the recipient of the state housing loan 00:17:41
- City staff explained that the borrower changed its name from 285 12th Street LP to 285 Development LP, which is affiliated with the East Bay Asian Local Development Corporation 00:17:41
- City staff said the state loan stays at about $20.4 million and the funding for the three city projects stays at about $14 million 00:17:41
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) noted the project is in District 2 and asked staff to confirm it came to this committee because part of the grant pays for street improvements around the development 00:21:04
- City staff confirmed this, explaining that the state program funds transportation projects within a mile of the housing site 00:21:54
- City staff named the funded projects as the 7th Street Connection in West Oakland, MLK Complete Streets, and the Broadway Transit Project 00:21:54
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked whether the name change was the only reason the item came back, and whether it changed any terms or deliverables 00:23:05
- City staff said only the name changes, and the state requires an adopted resolution with the new name before it will execute the agreements 00:23:45
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) asked how many housing units the development will have 00:24:15
- City staff said this site delivers 65 affordable units 00:24:23
- City staff said a second state award, for Liberation Park on 73rd Avenue, brings the combined total to the 168 units in the report 00:24:33
- City staff couldn't give a completion date but believed the project is under construction, and offered to follow up with Planning and Building and Housing and Community Development 00:24:49
$15.2 million construction contract for Embarcadero West rail safety, Phase 1 Item 4
Street safetyBiking and walkingFederal and state funding
The resolution awards a $15,240,586.98 construction contract to O.C. Jones & Sons, Inc. for Phase 1 of the Embarcadero West Rail Safety Project. It also authorizes change orders of up to 25 percent and adopts CEQA findings. Staff said freight and passenger trains, cars, bikes and pedestrians share this one-mile Jack London corridor with no separation from the tracks. The work would upgrade the rail crossings at Market and Oak Streets, add a train-responsive signal at Oak Street, and upgrade an overweight-vehicle crossing and route on Embarcadero West to heavyweight standards for trucks headed to the Port. Staff said that route would end the current overweight-truck route on 7th Street through West Oakland. The project also adds protected bike lanes and wayfinding signs. Staff said state Trade Corridor Enhancement Program grants pay for all of it, and construction would run from spring 2027 to 2029. 00:25:40
▶ Hear it A cyclist asks for speed humps, not just bike lanes · 0:57
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve the staff recommendation and forward it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:42:18Ayes: Noel Gallo, Ken Houston, Charlene Wang, Zac Unger. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said about 65 trains use the corridor each day and incidents are reported about once every five days 00:26:27
- City staff said the project modernizes the Market Street and Oak Street crossings with new gate arms and high-visibility crosswalks 00:26:27
- City staff said the upgraded overweight-truck route will eliminate the current overweight route on 7th Street through West Oakland 00:27:33
- City staff said the project adds protected bike lanes on Embarcadero West between Oak and Alice Streets, and on Oak Street 00:27:33
- City staff said construction would start in spring 2027 and finish in 2029, and that state Trade Corridor Enhancement Program grants fully fund the project 00:28:38
- City staff said the city received five bids, and after local-business bid discounts the Oakland-based O.C. Jones came in about 35 percent below the engineer's estimate 00:29:40
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked where the money would come from if change orders reached the full 25 percent, and whether it would take funds from other city projects 00:30:05
- City staff said change orders would also be paid entirely from state grants, so no other city project would lose money 00:31:52
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said the project is in District 2 and District 3, and asked whether staff had worked with the Port and rail stakeholders so the bike lanes don't conflict with freight traffic 00:32:12
- City staff said staff coordinated with the Port of Oakland, Union Pacific and the California Public Utilities Commission, and the designs let vehicles and emergency vehicles get through 00:33:22
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) relayed concerns from a dialysis center and from wheelchair users that the area needs an ADA-accessible loading zone 00:34:35
- City staff said that area is covered by a separate project, the 2nd Street Transportation Hub, which adds paratransit and accessible passenger loading and new curb ramps on 2nd Street between Harrison and Alice 00:35:39
- A councilmember asked about the role of the Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) and where the Bay Trail connection would lead 00:36:35
- City staff said the protected bike lanes connect people to the existing Bay Trail along the Water Street segment 00:36:44
- A councilmember asked that some of this kind of money go to District 7 next time, citing long-underserved infrastructure there 00:41:48
$1.1 million consultant to help negotiate Oakland's next garbage and recycling contracts Item 5
Trash and recyclingContracts and purchasing
The resolution hires HF&H Consultants, not to exceed $1,114,868, to help the city plan and negotiate its next solid waste franchise agreements. It also appropriates $200,000 from Fund 1710 for fiscal year 2026-27. Staff said the city's three franchise agreements, adopted in 2015, are its largest, with annual revenue of around $200 million. The Waste Management collection contract expires June 30, 2030. The California Waste Solutions recycling contract and the Waste Management disposal contract run through June 30, 2035. The stated priorities are rate affordability and transparency, a clean Oakland, meeting state recycling mandates, and more competition among bidders. HF&H's subconsultants are R3 Consulting Group, an Oakland small business, and Environmental Justice Solutions. 00:42:49
▶ Hear it Is Oakland's garbage franchise fee standard practice or rare? · 0:41
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:03:51Ayes: Noel Gallo, Ken Houston, Charlene Wang, Zac Unger. Moved by Ken Houston, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff recommended awarding the agreement to HF&H Consultants 00:43:32
- City staff said the three franchise agreements are the largest the city enters into, with annual revenue of around $200 million 00:44:33
- City staff said the city used one of two five-year extensions on the Waste Management collection contract, which now expires June 30, 2030 00:44:33
- City staff listed the city's priorities as rate affordability, transparency, a clean Oakland, state compliance, and competitive procurement 00:45:33
- City staff said a review panel picked HF&H as the most qualified and lowest-cost consultant, and that it has worked for the city for more than ten years 00:46:36
- City staff said subconsultant R3 Consulting Group is a certified local small business in Oakland 00:47:38
- City staff argued outside help levels the playing field, because the city negotiates these deals rarely while haulers negotiate all the time 00:47:38
- A councilmember asked that comments stay on the consultant hire, not the broader contracts with Waste Management or California Waste Solutions 00:49:27
- A councilmember asked whether HF&H handled the prior negotiation 00:49:49
- City staff said HF&H did not handle the prior negotiation, but has helped with annual rate increases, a performance evaluation of Waste Management, and hauler performance issues 00:50:21
- A councilmember asked whether reducing illegal dumping would be written into the new framework, and whether the consultant had talked with councilmembers in hard-hit districts 00:51:04
- City staff said the scope includes outreach to the public, to councilmembers, and to current and other service providers 00:51:41
- A councilmember questioned approving the consultant before it has talked to councilmembers 00:52:05
- City staff said the consultant is being hired to help define what a future franchise agreement should look like 00:52:12
- City staff said starting early gives other companies time to build the infrastructure they would need to bid 00:53:25
- A councilmember objected that Oakland collects a garbage franchise fee voters never approved, and asked how that money is used 00:54:38
- City staff said use of the franchise fee is shown in the city's adopted budget and offered to provide that information 00:55:42
- A councilmember said illegal dumping and blight have never been worse since the contract was signed, and that his own garbage bill went up to $300 00:56:00
- City staff responded that every California city they know of charges franchise fees through solid waste rates 00:57:12
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked which firm advised the city in the last negotiation, and whether this firm would bring the expertise to avoid repeating past mistakes 00:58:04
- City staff said they would follow up on the prior firm's name, noting that negotiation was around 2012, and that avoiding past mistakes is the intention 00:58:41
- City staff said the consultant will interview other haulers about what would make them willing to bid, so the procurement is more competitive 01:00:13
Collision repair contracts for city vehicles, amended to shift money to local shops Item 6
Contracts and purchasingSmall business
This is the second round of contracts for body-shop repair of the city fleet. Staff said the total is about $7 million over three years, split among several shops to bring in more Oakland businesses. In July the city awarded Quality, an Oakland shop, $1,050,000 and the incumbent Moeller Brothers $1,750,000 for heavy vehicles. This round covers the remaining $4.2 million. As posted, the awards were: Ron Dupratt Ford $1,400,000, Turbo Auto Body (Oakland-based) $700,000, and Experience Auto Body $350,000, all for light vehicles; and Falcon Collision Repair $1,750,000 for heavy vehicles. Each term runs January 1, 2027 to January 1, 2030, with two one-year renewal options. The committee amended the item to cut Ron Dupratt Ford to $700,000 and split that $700,000 equally among the remaining local businesses. 01:04:22
▶ Hear it Moving city body-shop work from a Dixon dealer to local shops · 0:29
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve as amended, cutting Ron Dupratt Ford's light-vehicle award from $1,400,000 to $700,000 and splitting that $700,000 equally among the remaining local businesses, and to forward the item to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:17:37Ayes: Noel Gallo, Ken Houston, Charlene Wang, Zac Unger. Moved by Ken Houston, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said the item returns after a July presentation and covers about $7 million in estimated value over three years 01:06:11
- City staff said the contract used to go to a single vendor, and staff split it into multiple awards to engage more Oakland businesses 01:07:13
- City staff said the July round awarded Oakland-based Quality $1,050,000 and the incumbent Moeller Brothers $1,750,000 for heavy-duty work 01:07:13
- City staff said purchasing reached out to 23 more light-duty shops, 15 of them in Oakland, and 19 heavy-duty shops, 7 of them in Oakland 01:08:15
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) thanked staff for responding to the council's push for Oakland businesses, and moved to cut Ron Dupratt Ford's share from 40 to 20 percent so local participation reaches 80 percent 01:10:46
- City staff said the change was doable, explaining that most of the fleet is Ford and needs a Ford dealer to calibrate driver-assist safety systems 01:11:29
- City staff said they didn't expect the reduction to affect operations 01:11:29
- City staff restated the amendment: Ron Dupratt Ford drops to $700,000, and that $700,000 is split equally among the remaining local businesses 01:12:33
- A councilmember asked whether the work would still get done under the change, and seconded after staff said it would 01:14:11
- City staff said staff will get the work done, and noted that staff and procurement are struggling with contracts and will be back often 01:13:51
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) thanked staff for listening, noted the body shops in District 2, and stressed that the quality of service must hold 01:14:53
Open Forum
Public comment on topics not on the agenda. Three speakers: one thanked city tree, public works and transportation staff; one spoke about filling the vacant Department of Transportation director job; one spoke about surveillance technology. 01:18:32
Public comment
- Item 2 (pending list): one speaker asked when a 373-page parks inventory and condition assessment, reviewed the day before by the Park and Recreation Advisory Committee, will come to this committee. They noted it recommends a comprehensive ADA compliance assessment.
- Item 3 (285 12th Street amendment): one speaker objected that members had no questions about a $35.8 million item, and asked where the housing is, who can live there, and who the developer is.
- Item 4 (Embarcadero West): two speakers. A cyclist welcomed the rail safety work but said the bikeway separation isn't continuous and bike lanes get blocked, and urged physical traffic calming such as speed humps. Another asked how many phases there will be, the total cost, and a cost breakdown by element. They also questioned the report's 'underinvested neighborhood' description and how the city can cut rail travel times.
- Item 5 (waste franchising consultant): one speaker hoped the process would cut illegal dumping. They also urged that the next contract end the city's role in collecting unpaid Waste Management bills through property liens. A second speaker waived their time.
- Item 6 (collision repair): one speaker argued that preferring local businesses while not giving residency or citizenship priority for city services is inconsistent. They asked about towing costs to out-of-town shops, including one about 60 miles away in Dixon, and in Concord, and thanked Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) for pushing for local vendors.
- Open forum: three speakers. One thanked specific tree service, public works and transportation staff for helping a relative with a sidewalk and tree problem. One noted the transportation director vacancy and the council's new charter power to approve the mayor's nominee, and urged that the next director prioritize traffic safety, ADA access including the consent decree, and paving. One pointed to San Diego's decision to end its license plate reader, Flock and smart streetlight programs, and to Oakland's community process on surveillance technology.
What's next
- Agenda items 3, 4, 5 and 6 (the 285 12th Street amendment, Embarcadero West, the waste franchising consultant, and collision repair) go to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. The collision repair contracts go as amended, with Ron Dupratt Ford reduced to $700,000.
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) asked for informational reports on the Waste Management and California Waste Solutions contracts, Civic Corps, and use of the garbage franchise fee; nothing was scheduled at this meeting, and the chair offered to help bring the requests to the Rules Committee. Staff also offered to work with him offline.
- Staff are to follow up on the 285 12th Street project's completion timeline with Planning and Building and with Housing and Community Development.
- Staff are to confirm which firm advised the city in its last solid waste negotiation, and offered information on how the franchise fee is budgeted.
- If the council awards the Embarcadero West contract in December, staff expect construction from spring 2027 to 2029.
- The Waste Management collection contract expires June 30, 2030; the California Waste Solutions recycling contract expires June 30, 2035.
Write to the Public Works and Transportation Committee before its next meeting: its comment form