· 7 items
Public Safety Committee, Tuesday, November 17
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Oakland's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Public Safety Committee Tuesday, November 17
7 items
Committee pending list Item 2
The committee's routine review of the schedule of outstanding items it has yet to take up, known as the pending list. 00:02:00
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee), to accept the determination of schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:03:59Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Carroll Fife. From the clerk's draft minutes
Vegetation management along wildfire evacuation routes Item 3
Emergency preparednessFire and paramedicsSchools and education
An informational report from the Oakland Fire Department, co-sponsored by Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee), on progress clearing hazardous vegetation and dead trees along the city's designated evacuation routes in the Oakland Hills, and on how residents are told where to evacuate. The fire department presented survey findings that many hill residents do not know their evacuation route or zone, named roads expected to jam in an evacuation, and discussed how students at Skyline High School and residents with disabilities would get out. 00:04:19
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7), to approve the staff recommendation and receive and forward the informational report to the December 15 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:54:43Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Ken Houston. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said the fire department inspects about 26,000 public and private parcels each year, clears roadsides and fire trails, and uses goat herds on difficult terrain. 00:06:51
- City staff reported that the Public Works tree division removed over 470 hazardous dead and dying trees along evacuation corridors in the last calendar year, much of it grant-funded. 00:09:03
- City staff reported that in a community survey 40 percent of residents had no specific evacuation route in mind. 00:11:49
- City staff said 52 percent of surveyed residents did not know their evacuation zone, and that the city is divided into more than 250 zones. 00:13:08
- City staff identified Snake Road, Broadway Terrace and Ascot Drive as long winding roads that would quickly jam, with Mountain Boulevard, Lincoln Avenue and Joaquin Miller Road as alternates. 00:15:16
- A councilmember asked how people are supposed to know where to go in the moment a wildfire breaks out. 00:19:13
- City staff clarified that the congested roads named are still active evacuation routes, only expected to be the most congested. 00:19:33
- City staff described layered notification using an evacuation mapping platform, AC Alert, wireless emergency alerts, and 25 outdoor sirens. 00:20:01
- City staff said the city has identified several shelters and recently opened a city-run shelter for an apartment fire within two hours, while working with the Red Cross on more. 00:21:42
- City staff confirmed, after a question from a councilmember's aide, that the tree removal work slated for October in the report has been completed. 00:23:28
- City staff said Public Works has an internal dashboard of the work that could likely be made public, pending work with IT, and offered to check on a timeline. 00:23:57
- A councilmember asked what the plan is to evacuate students at Skyline High School. 00:25:37
- City staff said Skyline High School asked the city to send police to evacuate students, which the city cannot promise, and that staff have suggested using the football field as an assembly point for buses. 00:26:11
- City staff said staff have floated closing the school on days of extreme fire hazard, while recognizing school funding depends on attendance. 00:27:11
- City staff said the school has a contract for 70 buses that staff recommend keeping on standby on red flag days, and that state bill SB 959 now allows a fire department-ordered school closure on particularly dangerous days. 00:29:51
- A councilmember asked for a simple step-by-step infographic that every councilmember could send to constituents. 00:30:32
- City staff said posters and cards with QR codes are already in circulation and videos on registering for AC Alert are coming in the next two months. 00:31:16
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked whether police and fire know which seniors are bedbound or disabled so they could be rescued. 00:33:12
- City staff said the city keeps no such list because registries elsewhere went unmaintained and are no longer recommended, urging family and neighborhood plans instead. 00:34:22
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said that answer was not good enough and that the city is responsible for protecting seniors and bedridden residents. 00:35:24
- City staff said the department can access PG&E's medical baseline roster and has requested two additional wheelchair-capable vans. 00:36:31
- City staff said the fire department has no helicopter of its own and relies on regional partners. 00:37:39
- A councilmember asked that the report be forwarded to the December 15 council meeting on consent, noting she could not make the motion as a non-member. 00:38:18
- The committee chair said she wants to follow up offline about the specific parcels raised in public comment. 00:52:05
- A councilmember urged proactive pruning of eucalyptus trees, naming the Grass Valley area. 00:52:32
- City staff said the next personal emergency preparedness training is December 10 and is listed on the website. 00:53:53
Convening as a special meeting of the full council
When Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) joined by Zoom, a quorum of the City Council was present, so the committee voted to adjourn and reconvene as a special meeting of the full council; under the agenda's notice, no final council action can be taken in that setting. 00:05:15
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to adjourn the Public Safety Committee meeting and convene as a special meeting of the full council at 5:05 PM. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:05:15
Police staffing and recruiting report Item 4
PolicingPublic employees
The police department's twice-yearly informational report on sworn and professional staffing, recruiting, academy results and officers on leave. Staff gave sworn field staffing as 612 as of the meeting date, and reported an academy that graduated 15 of about 40 trainees and 71 sworn employees on long-term leave. 00:55:13
▶ Hear it Can an injured young officer face disability retirement? · 0:34
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee), to receive and file the informational report in committee. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:28:12Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Carroll Fife. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff reported current sworn field staffing at 612, professional staff at 235.5 positions, and attrition of about six officers a month. 00:56:42
- City staff said the 197th academy graduated 15 on November 6, and the 198th academy, which began August 31, has 37 recruits and graduates March 6. 00:56:42
- The committee chair asked why so many trainees dropped from an academy that started with about 40, and whether the acceptance process is the problem, noting academies are expensive. 00:59:21
- City staff said the department uses the minimum state physical standard for entry and has recognized it is not enough, so some trainees resign once they face the physical demands. 01:00:02
- City staff said other trainees failed on academic learning domains or the driving portion. 01:01:02
- City staff said the failure rate is believed to be at the industry standard but did not have the figures. 01:02:08
- The committee chair called the staffing numbers a historic low and concerning, while noting a rise in Oakland residents among recruits. 01:02:24
- City staff said academies are budgeted for up to 50 trainees, so smaller classes produce salary savings for later academies. 01:03:13
- City staff said more than 70 people came to the latest testing, 64 passed and will begin background checks December 5. 01:04:24
- City staff said trainees who fail but keep a high enough GPA are recycled into the next academy. 01:05:54
- City staff described a weekly webinar for applicants and biweekly physical agility workshops to prepare candidates. 01:06:55
- A councilmember asked whether the report's 70 sworn employees on long-term leave had changed; police staff answered that it was 71, mostly on-duty injuries. 01:09:37
- City staff explained that officers on modified duty showing little improvement after about six months are sent home to recover or begin disability retirement, in consultation with the city's risk management. 01:12:59
- City staff said 25 sworn personnel are on transitional or modified duty, in addition to those fully off work. 01:16:02
- The committee chair questioned whether early disability retirement is any cheaper for the city than keeping officers on modified duty, and said it could be discussed offline. 01:20:05
- City staff said lateral recruitment is under way, with eight applicants meeting minimum qualifications a couple of weeks ago. 01:20:32
- City staff said one Piedmont and one BART trainee also graduated but are not counted among the 15, and promised information on reimbursement from those agencies. 01:21:04
ShotSpotter annual reports, continued use, and policy changes Item 5
Surveillance technologyPolicingViolence prevention
A resolution to accept the 2024 and 2025 annual reports on the ShotSpotter gunshot detection system, decide whether the city should keep using it, and approve changes to its surveillance use policy (Department General Order I-20). Police said the changes make every alert a top-priority call and add Oakland Housing Authority Police access. The contract runs through next September while police assess other vendors. 01:28:33
▶ Hear it Are most ShotSpotter alerts really negligent discharges? · 0:52
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the resolution to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:48:04Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said the policy now formally makes every ShotSpotter alert a priority-one call, as was already the practice. 01:29:02
- City staff said the policy was updated to reflect an agreement giving Oakland Housing Authority Police access to the system. 01:29:02
- City staff reported about 4,600 gunshot activations in 2025, down from about 6,000 the year before, alongside fewer shootings. 01:29:02
- City staff argued fast police response speeds medical care because medics do not enter a shooting scene until officers clear it. 01:30:07
- City staff described a homicide where ShotSpotter combined with license plate reader data located the shooting scene and led to three suspects being arrested and charged. 01:40:58
- City staff said a March 2026 review of 18 injury shootings found three never called in, with alerts arriving within 30 seconds to a minute versus about three minutes for calls. 01:42:01
- A councilmember asked whether other vendors with fewer errors could replace the ShotSpotter brand, citing Chicago moving away from that brand while still reserving money for similar technology. 01:44:26
- City staff said the latest one-year extension runs from September to next September, during which police will assess other vendors, adding that a radar-based option covered less area at much higher cost. 01:45:04
- City staff explained that negligent discharge is the category used when casings are found but no victim or struck object, not necessarily an accidental firing. 01:46:29
October 2026 911 system outage Item 6
Emergency preparednessPhone and internet serviceFire and paramedics
An informational report, requested by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), on the October 21 outage that took Oakland's 911 lines offline after copper and fiber lines outside the Edgewater dispatch center were severed in what staff said is believed to be theft. Calls went unanswered for about 69 minutes before rerouting to the Alameda County Sheriff, and full repairs took about 36 hours. Staff said hardening the lines depends on AT&T, new redundancy may need budget, and moving 911 off copper needs state approval. 01:48:27
▶ Hear it What happened to 911 calls made during the outage? · 1:04
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) moved, seconded by Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7), to receive and forward the informational report to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 02:30:06Ayes: Carroll Fife, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Charlene Wang, seconded by Ken Houston. From the clerk's draft minutes
- The committee chair said she agendized the report out of concern that the way to shut down the city's 911 system has now been publicized. 01:49:00
- City staff said the outage began at 8:37 PM on Wednesday, October 21, taking both 911 calls and the police dispatch system offline. 01:49:41
- City staff said calls were rerouted to the Alameda County Sheriff at 9:46 PM because the usual police-fire failover failed when both centers' lines were cut. 01:50:41
- City staff said fiber was restored at 8:44 PM the next day, copper lines about 7:13 AM the following morning, and police returned to their center at about 8:30 AM Friday. 01:51:42
- City staff said the public impact was 69 minutes between the lines going dark and calls being restored through the county. 01:52:43
- City staff said the cut happened in the public right-of-way outside the center, is under active criminal investigation, and is widely believed to be theft. 01:54:52
- City staff said there was no network backup because AT&T is the only fiber provider at the site, and 911 lines would still have depended on copper anyway. 01:55:53
- City staff said the fiber ran in plastic PVC conduit that should get metal sheathing, with tamper-proof locked boxes for the copper and surveillance in the area. 01:59:01
- City staff stressed that the lines are AT&T's infrastructure, so the city depends on AT&T to do the hardening. 02:00:08
- City staff said medium-term wireless redundancy may carry a budget cost, and moving 911 lines off copper requires authorization from the state Office of Emergency Services. 02:03:19
- The committee chair estimated about 60 calls came in during the 69-minute window and asked what happened to them. 02:05:26
- City staff said those callers very likely got a busy signal, and there is no data on whether any were major incidents. 02:06:10
- The committee chair asked for concrete timelines and whether AT&T is paid by the city, questioning why the city should pay for hardening. 02:06:34
- City staff said budget impacts of wireless and fiber redundancy should be clearer within weeks and will go into the budget process. 02:07:32
- City staff said 911 rates are set by the state utilities commission and paid by the state, though the city pays AT&T under other telecom contracts. 02:09:30
- The committee chair urged staff to play hardball with AT&T given the city funding it receives. 02:09:49
- City staff cautioned that the criminal investigation is open and the city attorney's office is reviewing contractual obligations, so staff should be careful in discussion. 02:10:09
- City staff said the state's NextGen 911 project has been paused and no police departments have moved to it. 02:11:18
- City staff said five network hub sites, including the 911 center, emergency operations center and police administration building, are candidates for hardening and a wireless overlay. 02:12:48
- City staff said AT&T has given no estimated date for the hardening work. 02:15:49
- A councilmember called the theft not a victimless crime and said she has asked state representatives about legislation to curb copper theft, citing dark streetlights in West Oakland. 02:16:29
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the response went as well as it could, recounted a person arrested in June for cutting an AT&T line on Baldwin Street, and called for law and order and full prosecution. 02:18:31
- The committee chair noted sheriff's dispatchers had no access to the police dispatch system and relayed calls by cell phone, and asked for a timeline on AT&T commitments, faster rerouting and long-term upgrades. 02:24:51
- City staff said staff could not provide a good timeline yet given the ongoing investigation and talks with AT&T. 02:26:57
- City staff speaking for the City Attorney's office, advised forwarding the report to the council as written with the information available to date. 02:28:37
Farewell to a departing staff member
Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) thanked a staff member, attending what was said to be their last committee meeting, for their service to the city. 02:34:44
Public comment
- Pending list (item 2): one speaker urged the city to fund exhaust ventilation systems for fire stations, saying the fire chief cannot use Measure NN money for them and the fumes are a health hazard.
- Evacuation-route vegetation (item 3): about six speakers. One asked for a map of the vegetation removal and better public outreach, and suggested neighbor-based plans for disabled residents. Two raised a city-owned parcel on Skyline Boulevard they said is not on the clearing list; one said it likely cost them their homeowner's insurance. One called for a long-term, data-driven, adequately funded mitigation plan the public can track. One offered help from a modeling and simulation company. One said Skyline High students cannot be evacuated, urged letters to parents, and suggested making Keller Avenue downhill-only and using vans from a nearby disability residence.
- Police staffing (item 4): three speakers. One asked how many officers have returned to the force, estimated academy retention at 37 percent, and suggested hiring trained candidates who fall short as administrative staff. One raised the citizenship requirement, field-training dropout data, cadet vacancies and Ceasefire staffing. One remote speaker said they were comfortable with low recruitment numbers and favored a shift to community policing.
- ShotSpotter (item 5): five speakers. Three supported keeping it, citing a Chicago vote to restore gunshot detection, police data on victims found only through alerts, and quick police response to shootings. Two opposed it, one also speaking for another signed-up speaker, citing a study finding no significant effect on arrests or homicides and a general preference for minimal surveillance.
- 911 outage (item 6): two speakers. One asked why AT&T took about 12 hours to start repairs, what priority calls were handled, and how protection would be paid for. One urged a publicly accessible cybersecurity process as systems move to fiber and digital.
- Open forum: three speakers. One described repeated break-ins and having no one to call for help. One said copper and catalytic converter theft is organized crime and asked when the city will contract for security at its facilities after a contract ended September 30. One remote speaker praised San Diego's decision to drop license plate readers and smart streetlights.
What's next
- The vegetation management and evacuation routes report goes to the December 15 City Council agenda on consent.
- The ShotSpotter resolution (annual reports, continued-use determination, and policy changes) goes to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent.
- The 911 outage report goes to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent, without a supplemental report. Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked for a later supplemental report with timelines on AT&T's commitments, rerouting improvements and long-term upgrades. Its timing was not set; she suggested bringing the item back in about three months, and staff said they could not give a timeline yet.
- IT staff expect to have the budget impacts of 911 network redundancy within the next few weeks and plan to bring them into the budget process.
- Police will assess alternative gunshot-detection vendors during the current ShotSpotter extension, which runs to next September.
- Fire department staff will check on a timeline for making the Public Works tree-removal dashboard public.
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) plans to follow up offline with Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) and staff on the parcels residents raised.
- The fire department's next personal emergency preparedness training is December 10; videos on registering for AC Alert are expected within two months.
- The 64 police applicants who passed recent testing begin background checks December 5; the 198th academy, with 37 recruits, graduates March 6.
- Police staff will get information on reimbursement from the BART and Piedmont police departments for their trainees in the Oakland academy.
Write to the Public Safety Committee before its next meeting: its comment form