· 2 items
Life Enrichment Committee, Tuesday, November 17
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Oakland's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Life Enrichment Committee Tuesday, November 17
2 items
Committee pending list Item 2
The committee's schedule of outstanding items, known as its pending list, which tracks matters waiting to come before the Life Enrichment Committee. The committee approved it as is. 00:06:43
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee), to approve the determination of schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:10:00Ayes: Noel Gallo, Carroll Fife, Charlene Wang, Ken Houston. Moved by Ken Houston, seconded by Carroll Fife. From the clerk's draft minutes
- The committee chair agreed with a public speaker about the housing waitlist, saying she herself had been on a waitlist for eleven years. 00:09:29
$800,000 more for substitute teachers in the city's Head Start program (ChildCare Careers, LLC) Item 3
Children and familiesPublic employeesPay and pensions
The Human Services Department's Early Childhood and Family Services Division contracts with ChildCare Careers, LLC for as-needed substitute teachers. The resolution adds $800,000 to the agreement, for a total not to exceed $2,050,000 over fiscal years 2022 to 2027. City staff said the substitutes keep classrooms in line with community care licensing, state and federal rules so the program can stay open, and that the money is already identified, with no new funding requested. The contract ends June 30, 2027. Discussion centered on why the program relies on substitutes: staff said 24 teaching positions are vacant because the city's teacher pay isn't competitive. 00:10:12
▶ Hear it Why can't the city's Head Start fill its teaching jobs? · 0:54
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to recommend the resolution to the City Council, forwarding it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:26:23Ayes: Noel Gallo, Carroll Fife, Charlene Wang, Ken Houston. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said the item raises the contract by $800,000 for its final year. 00:11:09
- City staff said the division is opening a new five-year request for proposals to find more vendors, and that the root problem is the need to hire and pay staff properly so the program depends less on substitutes. 00:11:09
- City staff said the amendment lets the program meet community care licensing, state and federal rules and keep its doors open while the root causes are addressed. 00:11:09
- City staff said the funding is already identified and no new money is requested or appropriated. 00:12:17
- A councilmember asked staff to explain for the public why this is the third waiver and why the small local business competitive bidding requirement was waived. 00:16:49
- City staff said the waiver was removed from this amendment, and that the original contract had one because there were no qualified bidders then. 00:17:15
- City staff said no small local business could meet the background check, health, credential and training requirements at the time, and that the new request for proposals includes outreach with that priority in mind. 00:17:15
- A councilmember asked for the current vacancy rate in the Head Start program. 00:18:25
- City staff said 24 teaching positions at different levels are vacant today. 00:18:34
- City staff said long-serving teachers are retiring faster than they can be replaced, and the city isn't competitive in a region with a teacher shortage. 00:18:51
- City staff said applicants are turning down job offers because the pay is too low. 00:18:51
- A councilmember asked whether the HR requisition process was the problem, and staff said it was not. 00:19:25
- City staff said the problem is a lack of interest at the wage the city pays. 00:19:43
- A councilmember said the city should fix the pay problem, and seconded the motion. 00:19:48
- The committee chair responded to a public speaker's concern about the requirements, saying that as a former registered child care provider she knows how important full training is for people who care for children. 00:19:52
- The committee chair noted that the federal government has cut resources, and asked what the city's long-term plan is to address funding and offer competitive pay. 00:20:53
- City staff said the program has been on an under-enrollment plan since 2024 and has used mechanisms in the labor agreement, such as premium pay for higher permits, to raise teacher pay. 00:21:30
- City staff said a 2024 change-in-scope request to the federal Office of Head Start, which included a plan to address teacher pay, sat with federal officials for over a year, and the program then lost the funding the plan needed. 00:22:31
- City staff said the pay gap was not addressed in labor negotiations, that a 2024 wage compensation study is included in the report, and that, as staff understand it, the council has authority to adjust pay for certain job classifications. 00:22:31
- The committee chair asked whether the council could take this up in the coming budget cycle. 00:23:38
- City staff said pay could be discussed in the budget, that other Head Start programs face the same problem, and that a coalition is looking at local workforce dollars to help recruit Head Start staff. 00:23:50
- City staff said the program hires fully qualified staff and has Oakland Children's Initiative funding for a new pathway that brings teachers in through an online CDA credential program while they finish their degrees. 00:24:38
- The committee chair said she would like to move away from outsourcing, and cited the staff report as saying the city pays the contractor $38 to $46 an hour for substitutes. 00:25:38
- City staff clarified that the $38 to $46 an hour is what the city pays the company. 00:25:55
- The committee chair asked what the contractor pays its workers and, when staff said the company has declined to share that, questioned that it won't say what it pays the workers the city is ultimately paying for. 00:25:58
- City staff said the contract ends June 30, 2027. 00:26:14
Public comment
- Pending list (item 2): one speaker said every Oakland Housing Authority waitlist is closed and the average wait is about nine years, and asked for an open discussion of housing need and immigration.
- Substitute teacher contract (item 3): two speakers. One questioned whether enough substitutes can meet the many qualification requirements, such as coursework, fingerprinting, first aid and CPR, and asked what the actual need is. The other spoke about children's health, healthy food, and using closed school sites for food programs.
- Open forum: two speakers. One described a 1991 letter by Coretta Scott King opposing repeal of penalties on employers who hire undocumented workers. The other talked about an apology they made at an earlier meeting for remarks about a Housing Authority employee. One other speaker, called for item 2 and again for open forum, wasn't present.
What's next
- The ChildCare Careers contract amendment goes to the December 1 City Council meeting on the consent calendar.
- The division is opening a new five-year request for proposals for substitute staffing, with outreach to small local businesses; the current contract ends June 30, 2027.
- Staff and the committee chair discussed taking up Head Start teacher pay in the upcoming budget cycle; the committee chair asked to be included in those conversations.
Write to the Life Enrichment Committee before its next meeting: its comment form