CivicFM
Oakland

· 6 items

Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, November 17

What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Oakland's next episode.

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Finance and Management Committee Tuesday, November 17

6 items

The recording · Agenda

Committee's pending list Item 2

The committee's routine review of its schedule of outstanding items, its pending list. It was accepted as is. 00:08:18

  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to accept the determination of schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:11:05Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes

Update on city-owned parking garages Item 3

Parking

An informational report from the Finance Department on how the city-owned parking garages are run and how they're doing financially, how the parking operator is performing, and the alternatives. In September the committee continued the item and asked staff whether to bring back gates, for usage figures for each garage, why citations have varied, what other California cities do, and which deferred maintenance comes first. Staff said garage revenue is still about 17% below pre-pandemic levels and that the garages netted roughly $880,000 on about $8.5 million gross last fiscal year. Staff recommends returning to gated garages, at an estimated $1.5 million one-time plus about $1.1 million a year for attendants, and is running a request for proposals for a long-term operator. The committee received and filed the report. 00:11:29

▶ Hear it What do the city's parking garages actually earn? · 1:07

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to receive and file the informational report. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:40:05Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's draft minutes
  • City staff reported that garage revenues remain about 17% below pre-pandemic levels and that citation revenue is only a small share of garage revenue 00:11:55
  • City staff said staff recommends returning to a gated system, estimated at about $1.5 million in one-time capital costs for the six garages plus about $1.12 million a year for attendants 00:12:57
  • The committee chair said she was very concerned that the city doesn't make money off its garages, though Oakland isn't alone in that 00:14:27
  • City staff estimated that a gated system could bring in $2 million to $3 million more a year in gross revenue, assuming full compliance and pre-pandemic usage 00:16:57
  • City staff said the garages netted roughly $880,000 on about $8.5 million gross last fiscal year, and that after the gating and staffing costs the added net would be about $1 million or less 00:17:23
  • The committee chair complained that garages are closed on key dates, including weekends, citing a closed garage during the Black Joy Parade, and asked when staff would bring specific budget requests 00:19:19
  • City staff said the city is issuing a request for proposals for a long-term operator contract and expects it to be done within the next year 00:19:59
  • City staff said staff plans to put options for each garage, with their funding, into a budget proposal for the council's biennial budget, and to extend the current contract a calendar year to allow the transition 00:21:11
  • City staff noted that the garages need significant capital investment and life-safety work if the city keeps operating them 00:22:18
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) recommended making license plate readers one of the deferred-maintenance priorities so non-payers are caught 00:23:59
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked staff to look at what a full-day rate goes for in Bay Area garages, since not all city garages have a daily rate 00:24:42
  • City staff said most garage rates haven't been updated in several years, and that staff plans a market analysis and fee update in this year's master fee schedule amendment 00:25:33
  • City staff said the city already uses automatic license plate readers but they work poorly inside enclosed concrete garages 00:25:33
  • A councilmember asked whether the city is behind on paying the garage operator, and whether the money owed is already budgeted 00:26:49
  • City staff said the operator has been paid through the end of July and staff is finalizing the steps to issue the pending check 00:26:29
  • City staff said the city has budget authority but needs the contract extension on the next item for contract authority to cut checks 00:27:03
  • A councilmember noted that a couple of garages stood out for losing revenue in an earlier report, and asked why the city doesn't simply use gates 00:27:32
  • City staff explained that gates are the surest way to make everyone pay but cost more to run because of attendant staff, and that staff is also looking at systems that read every plate on entry and exit, chosen garage by garage 00:28:49
  • A councilmember asked why EV chargers installed in many garages are not working 00:30:49
  • City staff said the city is contractually obligated to provide EV charging in various garages, that he hadn't known they weren't working, and that he would look into it 00:31:12
  • City staff said the current timeline would bring a recommendation for a new vendor to the committee around March, in the spring 00:32:37
  • The committee chair asked whether WiFi problems at the Dalzell and City Center West garages have been fixed so that citations can be issued 00:32:59
  • City staff said connectivity is being worked on inside the city as a safety issue, whichever vendor operates the garages 00:34:33
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) pointed to EV chargers at what she believed was the 12th Street garage, financed by an outside energy provider, as a model to expand to other garages 00:39:12

One-year extension of the parking garage operator contract Item 4

ParkingContracts and purchasing

A resolution to extend the city's contract with City of Oakland Parking Partners, which runs the city's parking facilities, by up to one year, through December 31, 2027, for a total over the amended term not to exceed $4,133,013. It waives the competitive request for proposals requirement and adopts CEQA exemption findings. Staff said the contract began in 2014, has been extended three times, and expires December 31, 2026. The extension gives the city time to finish a new procurement, with no change to the current payment rate. The committee sent it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. 00:40:10

▶ Hear it Who is behind the city's parking garage operator? · 0:45

  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the item to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:53:03Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes
  • City staff said the original agreement dates to 2014 and, after three extensions, expires December 31, 2026 00:40:54
  • City staff said the amendment adds one year with no change to the current payment rate while the city completes its request for proposals 00:41:56
  • The committee chair said she would support the extension even though a couple of months ago she wanted the contract to end this year, because a thorough procurement takes time 00:42:09
  • The committee chair asked staff to work with the current operator during the extension on enforcement, access, and safety capital improvements 00:42:09
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) urged that easier maintenance and garage upgrades go ahead during the procurement rather than pause 00:42:53
  • City staff said staff is looking for prior-year savings to carry forward for repairs and won't wait for a new contract to start needed improvements 00:43:34
  • A councilmember pointed to several lots that showed zero revenue in the earlier report and asked that they be fixed 00:44:29
  • City staff explained that some lots were donated on the condition that parking stays free for commuters, and that others collect through parking meters, so that money is counted as meter revenue rather than garage revenue 00:45:09
  • City staff said City of Oakland Parking Partners is a joint venture of two companies, and that the city got its partnership filings 00:52:15
  • The committee chair noted that rate changes to draw more volume have been considered over the years 00:52:49

How well the city pays its contractors on time Item 7

Contracts and purchasingSmall business

An informational report, requested by Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee), on how the city's prompt payment policy is working. The policy sets deadlines for paying vendors once they're under contract. The committee first heard it June 9 and continued it, with members to send staff questions for a supplemental report. Staff reports about 96% compliance, but business groups said the number leaves out subcontractors and the time invoices sit in departments; the Director of Finance said much of vendors' delay comes from work starting before a contract exists. The committee convened as a special meeting of the full council so another councilmember could speak, then continued the item to its January 26, 2027 meeting for an update. 00:53:38

  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to adjourn the committee meeting and convene as a special meeting of the full City Council, a quorum of the council being present. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:31:55
  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to continue the item to the January 26, 2027 Finance and Management Committee, with a supplemental report on what the administration and finance are doing to manage compliance and software purchases, the legislative timeline and implementation, and the administration's work plan for contracting improvements. Result: continued, 4-0. 01:37:55Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes
  • The committee chair said she brought the report because many city contractors, including small businesses and nonprofits, are not paid on time 00:53:48
  • The committee chair said the reported compliance rate of over 90% doesn't match what she hears on the ground 00:53:48
  • Bradley Johnson (Director of Finance) said average compliance over the last three or four years is 96% and that the policy applies to Oakland vendors 00:55:37
  • Bradley Johnson (Director of Finance) said much of the delay vendors experience comes from work starting before a contract exists, which falls outside the prompt payment timelines 00:55:37
  • A councilmember said his office has been working with the city administration on contracting and prompt payment reform and will bring legislation 01:16:11
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) said her office spent months of her first year in office tracking down payments for small businesses and nonprofits 01:16:33
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked who has taken over the work an assistant city administrator who has since left had been leading 01:17:35
  • City staff said another assistant city administrator will lead the city's Disparity Study response, supported by an interim department director 01:18:17
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked why late-payment interest payments rose sharply after 2022, when there were 167 01:19:36
  • City staff said finance sees no clear data-driven reason for the swings and could only speculate about staff turnover or contract cycles 01:19:54
  • City staff said the city's financial system has no comprehensive contract management to track subcontractors, and that finance is working on electronic checks to cut delays 01:21:06
  • City staff said the administration is exploring a system that can track payments to subcontractors in the small and local business program 01:22:03
  • City staff said the report has no comparisons with other jurisdictions and offered to look into them 01:22:40
  • The committee chair said she would move to hold the item in committee because much more work remains, and asked for coordination with her office on legislation 01:22:55
  • A councilmember called for a work plan to fix the problems public speakers raised, and said a requested breakdown of payments to disadvantaged businesses was missing 01:24:17
  • A councilmember asked how capital improvement projects can have a 54% compliance rate yet only about $29,000 in interest penalties 01:25:20
  • City staff suggested many capital payments may run only a day or two late, which drives noncompliance without much interest, though he wasn't sure 01:26:32
  • City staff agreed to break down the list of noncompliant vendors by local, small local, and other businesses in the next supplemental report 01:27:32
  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) asked whether the city should be responsible for subcontractors being paid promptly or should put that duty on prime contractors 01:27:48
  • City staff recommended changing contract templates and rules to require primes to pay subcontractors, with a way to track their compliance 01:28:09
  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) raised vendors who start work without a signed contract or don't understand how to get paid 01:28:57
  • City staff said departments directing work without a contract is unacceptable, puts the city and vendors at risk, and is being stopped 01:29:28
  • City staff said the city needs to make it easier for vendors to get under contract, including simpler insurance requirements and fewer separate forms to sign 01:30:24
  • A councilmember spoke during the special meeting, drawing on experience as a contractor to say primes should be required to pay subcontractors within fifteen to twenty days, and that some subcontractors waited a year to be paid 01:31:59
  • The committee chair asked the update to cover what the administration and finance are doing to manage compliance now, including software purchases 01:34:21
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for the legislative timeline and implementation as part of the update 01:34:53

Annual Equal Access to Services report Item 5

Civil rights and equityImmigrants

The annual informational report on how well the city complied with its Equal Access to Services Ordinance in fiscal year 2025-26. The ordinance requires city departments to provide services to residents with limited English. Staff reported that 42% of residents speak a language other than English at home and that about 600 of roughly 3,000 public-contact employees are bilingual. Combined Spanish and Chinese bilingual staffing reached 19% against a 14% goal. The committee forwarded the report to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. 01:38:09

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee), to receive the report and forward it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:48:59Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Janani Ramachandran. From the clerk's draft minutes
  • City staff described the city's Equal Access program as one of the first of its kind in the country 01:38:47
  • City staff said that, by census data, 42% of residents speak a language other than English at home, Spanish being the most common, followed by Chinese 01:39:53
  • City staff said about 600 of the city's roughly 3,000 public-contact employees are bilingual 01:40:53
  • City staff said the combined Spanish and Chinese bilingual staffing goal is 14% and the city reached 19% last fiscal year, though results vary by department 01:40:53
  • City staff said the Equal Access unit has two staff and contracts with five language companies, each covering over 100 languages 01:42:08
  • A councilmember asked for year-over-year comparisons and flagged that Parks and Recreation's Spanish-speaking public-contact share fell from 37% to 9% 01:44:02
  • City staff said, for Parks and Recreation, that the drop came from a change in method: earlier reports divided by the department's roughly 290 full-time equivalents, which overstated the share given its many part-time staff 01:45:50
  • A councilmember said her staff found a number of public hotlines without messages in other languages, citing MACRO as one that needs them 01:47:12
  • City staff offered to quickly create multilingual phone messages for any department that sends a script 01:48:03

Translation and interpretation contract increases Item 6

Civil rights and equityImmigrants

A resolution to amend the city's on-call contracts with International Contact, Inc. and Accent on Languages, Inc. for translation, interpretation, and bilingual testing. Each agreement increases by $400,000 to a total not to exceed $650,000 and is extended by three years. Staff said the services are used as needed, the higher cap doesn't commit the money, and it lets the city respond quickly in emergencies. The committee forwarded it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. 01:49:11

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the item to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:58:56Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's draft minutes
  • City staff said the contract amounts are rarely used but need to be available right away for emergencies and community outreach 01:49:39
  • City staff said the original request for proposals was meant for five years, the city first awarded two-year terms, and this brings them to the full five 01:51:10
  • City staff said both vendors are minority-owned small business enterprises 01:51:10
  • City staff said raising the cap doesn't obligate funds but gives room to respond to emergencies and disasters 01:51:10
  • A councilmember backed the larger cap for emergency response, citing the city's El Niño and disaster preparations, and moved the item 01:52:51
  • A councilmember asked whether the 311 system and app will become multilingual, saying areas with more residents of limited English file fewer 311 reports 01:53:31
  • City staff said phone interpretation is available to all departments, connecting in under ten seconds for Spanish and Chinese, and promised another round of staff training this year 01:54:34
  • City staff said 311 staff have access to the interpretation line, but whether online portals can offer other languages depends on each vendor's platform 01:55:47

Public comment

  • Pending list (item 2): one speaker asked when an expired security contract for city facilities would be resolved, questioned a parking-validation arrangement with an ice center, saying it's unclear whether it's a signed contract or a verbal arrangement, and raised the fire chief's lack of money for station exhaust ventilation.
  • Parking garages (item 3): two speakers. One said city vehicles take up garage space, asked for transparency on the ice center validation, and questioned enforcement timing after getting a ticket. Another noted the Conference Center parking lot wasn't in the report. A third person who hadn't signed up asked to speak, and the chair declined.
  • Parking contract extension (item 4): three speakers. One asked for a joint Finance and Transportation presentation that treats garage and street parking pricing as one system. One asked who owns City of Oakland Parking Partners and where its performance evaluation is. One suggested lower rates might bring in more revenue.
  • Prompt payment (item 7): about eight speakers, most representing business coalitions and chambers of commerce (African American, Metro, Chinatown). They said the 96% figure leaves out subcontractors and the time invoices sit in departments, and cited about $394,000 in late-payment interest and an audit finding of a 47-day average payment cycle. They asked for separate reporting for small local businesses, contract terms requiring primes to pay subs, a way for vendors to check invoice status, and a follow-up report by February 2027. Two business owners described long waits for payment. One said a June 2025 training invoice is still unpaid and alleged a city department manager blocked it in retaliation for her past complaints. One speaker demanded a commitment to legislation rather than simply receiving and filing the report.
  • Equal Access report (item 5): no public speakers; those called were not present or did not speak.
  • Translation contracts (item 6): one speaker said the city doesn't offer real interpretation at its meetings, contrasting it with school board meetings, and questioned the language data.
  • Open forum: two speakers. One said the online sign-up to speak discourages participation and asked councilmembers to try it themselves. Another asked for reports on parking pilot programs, including Lake Merritt meters, Chinatown loading, and Montclair demand-responsive meters.

What's next

  • The parking operator contract extension (item 4), the Equal Access report (item 5), and the translation contract amendments (item 6) go to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent.
  • Prompt payment (item 7) returns to the January 26, 2027 Finance and Management Committee with a supplemental report covering compliance management and software purchases, the legislative timeline, and the administration's contracting work plan. Staff also agreed to break down noncompliant vendors by local, small local, and other.
  • Staff expect to bring a recommended new garage operator around March 2027, after the request for proposals.
  • Staff plan a market analysis of garage rates and a fee update in this year's master fee schedule amendment, and to put garage options and capital needs into the biennial budget proposal.
  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee)'s office said it will bring legislation on prompt payment and contracting reform; Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) asked to coordinate.
  • Staff said they would look into the non-working EV chargers in the garages.
  • Equal Access staff offered to include year-to-year trend data in the next annual report and to run another round of interpretation training this year.

Write to the Finance and Management Committee before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error