· 4 items
Community and Economic Development Committee, Tuesday, November 17
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Oakland's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Community and Economic Development Committee Tuesday, November 17
4 items
Welcome to Oakland High School students
The chair welcomed students from Oakland High School's Law and Social Justice Academy who were attending the meeting. 00:02:12
Schedule of outstanding committee items Item 2
The committee's routine review of its list of pending items. The administration reported no changes, and the committee accepted the list as is. 00:02:44
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to accept the schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 3-0, Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) excused. 00:05:07Ayes: Carroll Fife, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Absent: Janani Ramachandran. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff reported for the administration that there were no changes to the pending list. 00:02:57
Annual report on anti-displacement programs and the Rent Adjustment Program Item 3
Renters and tenantsHomelessness
The Housing and Community Development Department's informational report for fiscal year 2025-2026 on its anti-displacement programs. It covers homelessness prevention, eviction prevention, fair housing, code compliance relocation, and the Rent Adjustment Program's annual report. It is the first year of reporting under the anti-displacement strategic action plan the council accepted in March 2026. Staff said the RAP annual report needs council approval, so the committee forwarded the report to the full council. The report covers rental aid, eviction defense, rent registry compliance, RAP fees and staffing, and when a lead-settlement-funded lead abatement program and a proactive rental inspection program will start. 00:05:27
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to accept the staff recommendation, receive the report, and forward it to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent, with staff to provide a supplemental report correcting typographical and other errors, including table 13. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:16:32Ayes: Carroll Fife, Janani Ramachandran, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Carroll Fife, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff explained that the department's Community Development Division implements the anti-displacement strategic action plan, which the council accepted in March 2026. 00:05:58
- City staff said homelessness prevention is the top priority because Black residents make up 56% of Oakland's unhoused population but 21% of its overall population. 00:10:13
- City staff reported that the targeted homelessness prevention collaborative delivered close to $4 million in direct financial assistance to stabilize more than 800 households, counting all funding sources. 00:13:28
- City staff said point-in-time counts fell between 2024 and 2026, with homelessness among Black residents down about 14% compared with 19.6% overall, which shows there is more work to do for the most at-risk residents. 00:14:10
- City staff said the city's own share of the homelessness prevention program was about $3.6 million from CDBG and Fund 1870. 00:14:10
- City staff said the eviction prevention contract was $1.1 million from Fund 1870 and that the collaborative met or exceeded most of its goals. 00:15:10
- City staff reported close to 60 relocation payments under the code compliance relocation program, owner-paid and program-paid, totaling about $276,000. 00:17:11
- City staff said more than 170 households were displaced by fires in the past year, and that next year's scope of work and budget will include a contingency plan for future emergencies. 00:18:13
- City staff reported that rent registry compliance reached 72% at the end of the fiscal year, up from 55% in the first year owners had to comply. 00:20:15
- City staff said almost 300 petitions were filed with the Rent Adjustment Program last year, and that the counseling team served almost 4,000 community members. 00:21:17
- City staff credited improved RAP finances mainly to the council-approved fee increase from $101 to $137 per covered unit, plus fee collection and cost controls. 00:24:27
- City staff said RAP is authorized for 33 staff and has 11 vacancies. 00:24:27
- City staff said a racial equity review of RAP will produce recommendations, including proposed ordinance amendments and reprocurement of all contracted services. 00:25:21
- City staff said the city hopes to finish negotiations with Alameda County over the remaining lead settlement funds, and that a working group will bring the terms and the lead hazard abatement program design to the council in the first half of 2027. 00:26:25
- City staff said the department's response to three mass displacement events in six weeks depended on an emergency authorization resolution and on Fund 1870, the Affordable Housing Trust Fund. 00:27:27
- A councilmember asked whether the $5 million RAP surplus would recur and whether it would be held in reserve or spent down. 00:45:45
- City staff called it a one-time surplus that came from recovering delinquent fees after years of structural deficit, and said it would let RAP unfreeze 11 positions, since only 22 of its 33 authorized positions are filled. 00:46:09
- City staff said ongoing RAP positions would be paid from the RAP fund, which is supported by the fee in the master fee schedule, through the biennial budget process. 00:48:34
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) praised staff's response to the fires that hit her district. 00:49:01
- City staff said Community Development and Engagement and most of the department's staffing are funded by Fund 1870. 00:49:29
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked what the goal was for the small property owner representation contract, which the report showed served 84 applicants. 00:50:23
- A speaker answered for the rental housing association contractor that the contract's original goal of about 240 was lowered to 120 to match the number of RAP petitions. 00:52:02
- A speaker said most owners who call the small-owner program don't know they are responsible for RAP fees, rent registry, and business license tax. 00:52:51
- A speaker said a figure in the report's demographic table appeared to be wrong, with 3% that should read 33%. 00:54:49
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) pressed for better demographic data from the small-owner contract, noting that other providers report clearly. 00:56:32
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) said the data suggested that most of the small property owners served don't live in Oakland, and asked HCD to verify the contractor's figures. 00:57:18
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked for an update to the committee before the end of the fiscal year, possibly in the spring. 00:58:14
- City staff apologized for any reporting error, committed to providing updated numbers, and said HCD will competitively reprocure all contracted RAP services. 00:58:52
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked for a realistic timeline for launching the proactive rental inspection program. 01:00:34
- City staff answered for Planning and Building that the department has developed a program but is waiting on HCD's negotiation with Alameda County, which will shape the program, given about 100,000 rental properties in the city. 01:01:06
- City staff said the department must bring the program to the council for approval of new fees in the master fee schedule. 01:02:45
- City staff said community engagement on the inspection program's design may start as early as next month. 01:03:28
- City staff said the inspection program would be cost-recovery, started with settlement funds, and noted that Elizabeth Lake (City Administrator, Interim) had sent a letter to coalition partners on the status of both programs. 01:04:30
- City staff said staff would keep members informed of community engagement and that both programs would return to the committee. 01:05:33
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked staff to communicate consistently with community groups about the lead and inspection programs. 01:05:58
- The committee chair asked that table 13 of the report be updated with accurate data before it goes to the full council. 01:06:59
- City staff said the RAP annual report requires council approval and could go on consent. 01:07:23
- City staff said the targeted homelessness prevention program records all its data, including demographics, in a single database with an embedded risk assessment. 01:08:57
- The committee chair asked why some tables did not break out Latino and Hispanic residents. 01:10:12
- City staff said eviction prevention providers use different terms and methods to collect racial and ethnic data, and that staff are working toward more consistent metrics. 01:10:43
- The committee chair noted that ZIP code 94612, around downtown, had 1,377 eviction notices. 01:11:48
- The committee chair asked whether move-in specials at newer developments, with rents rising after the first year, were contributing to eviction notices. 01:12:20
- City staff said nonpayment of rent is the leading cause of eviction, that it is mainly an affordability issue, and that an unfrozen analyst position would allow deeper analysis. 01:13:34
- The committee chair suggested the data may support bringing back a guaranteed income pilot to keep people housed. 01:14:27
Oakport Field license with Oakland United and regional park zoning designation Item 4
Parks and treesZoning and plansYouth
Two ordinances, files 27-0189 and 27-0190. The first applies a Regional-Serving Park designation type to the Open Space zoning for the Martin Luther King Jr. Regional Shoreline area and adjacent open space parcels, including Oakport Field (agenda). Staff described this as a cleanup that lets current uses continue. The second authorizes a 15-year license agreement with the nonprofit Oakland United Club, Inc. or its affiliate to repair, maintain, improve, operate, and schedule the Oakport Field athletic complex at 5815 Oakport Street. The base fee is $500 per month, rising 3% a year, plus 15% of net sponsorship revenue once initial capital repairs are paid off. Staff said at least 55% of field time would be free public use and that the city would control fees. The field would remain a public park. 01:16:41
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward both ordinances to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:42:40Ayes: Carroll Fife, Janani Ramachandran, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Carroll Fife, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's draft minutes
- City staff said the parks department has few playable athletic fields and decided in 2024 to put out a request for proposals for Oakport Field, then conditionally awarded it in 2025 to the Oakland Soccer Club, now under Oakland United. 01:17:57
- City staff described the site as two fields in poor condition, with a rundown fence and bathroom, behind the EBMUD facility near the Coliseum. 01:19:19
- City staff said the license covers only the athletic fields, not the surrounding wetlands or trail. 01:19:19
- City staff said the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission voted on October 14 to support the license agreement. 01:20:31
- City staff said the field would have to be available for free public use at least 55% of the time, through drop-in play, free youth programs, or the city's own allotment. 01:21:40
- City staff said an advisory council with a city seat and an unaffiliated community member would inform the access policy, which the city must approve. 01:21:40
- City staff said fees would be set in the city's master fee schedule and the city could take back scheduling if the operator breaches the agreement. 01:22:41
- City staff said sponsorship and advertising revenue would first pay off an initial capital project of about $4 million, after which the city gets 15% and the rest goes back into the field. 01:23:41
- City staff said the deal would bring in a little over $9 million in private capital over the term, and that the low rent reflects these in-kind benefits rather than a market rate. 01:24:46
- City staff said the area's open space zoning never received a required category, that the advisory commission recommended the regional-serving park designation the previous night, and that the change keeps existing uses as they are. 01:24:46
- The committee chair asked which community organizations Oakland United works with and who would have access to the field. 01:26:40
- A guest presenter said Oakland United serves as the infrastructure backbone of a coalition of more than 40 free or affordable youth sports programs serving over 27,000 youth. 01:27:25
- A guest presenter said the group spent more than a year engaging existing users, local programs, and schools around Oakport. 01:28:30
- A guest presenter said some program partners who wanted to speak on Zoom couldn't register because of an error. 01:29:34
- A guest presenter said Oakland United has raised over $7 million in five-year commitments, mostly from individual philanthropy, and is fiscally sponsored while it waits for IRS nonprofit status. 01:30:34
- A guest presenter said the group is applying for a State Parks Program grant together with supplybank.org, which is doing shoreline restoration nearby. 01:31:58
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) called the project an opportunity for East Oakland and asked how other youth soccer groups would get to use the field. 01:32:37
- A guest presenter said Oakland United won't field its own teams, and that the field would be a multi-sport surface lined for several sports. 01:33:41
- A guest presenter said spectator seating is still being decided through community engagement, possibly with movable bleachers. 01:35:30
- A councilmember's aide conveyed Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7)'s support for both ordinances on his behalf. 01:36:35
- City staff confirmed that each of the two ordinances requires two readings at the council. 01:36:50
Public comment
- Item 2 (pending list): one speaker urged the city to rewrite its housing preference order to prioritize groups such as veterans, seniors, and people with health conditions, pointing to Berkeley's list as a model.
- Item 3 (anti-displacement report): eight people spoke. Three members of the Oakland Tenants Union backed a proactive rental inspection program; one of them urged the city to get it done in 2027 without further delay. One of them disputed the landlord group's framing of the RAP fee, saying half of it can legally be passed on to tenants.
- Item 3, continued: a tenant legal services director praised the eviction defense programs, the Rent Adjustment Program, and the city's response to the recent fires. A public health and asthma group urged urgency in spending the 2019 lead paint settlement funds, citing years of delays.
- Item 3, continued: a representative of the East Bay Rental Housing Association supported the plan but said small property owners are under strain. They cited a 36% RAP fee increase while allowable rent increases were 8.8%, and that 91% of eviction notices are for nonpayment.
- Item 3, continued: one speaker asked for a ten-year report on housing production, costs, and time to occupancy. Another criticized the report's terminology and racial categories and said gentrification and sanctuary city status drive displacement of Black residents.
- Item 4 (Oakport Field): three people spoke. A representative of supplybank.org, developer of a nearby nonprofit campus, and a high school student from East Oakland both supported the license, with the student citing long bus rides to distant fields. A third speaker raised equity concerns and asked what security and safety measures the site would have.
- The clerk found no speaker cards for three Zoom participants asked whether they had signed up for Item 4, and Oakland United said some of its partners couldn't register because of an error.
- Open forum: one speaker talked about statewide demographic change.
What's next
- The anti-displacement and Rent Adjustment Program annual report goes to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent, with a supplemental report correcting table 13 and any typographical errors.
- Both Oakport ordinances (the regional-serving park designation and the 15-year Oakland United license) go to the December 1 City Council agenda on consent. Each ordinance requires two readings.
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) asked for an update to the committee before the end of the fiscal year, possibly in the spring, with verified demographic data from the small property owner representation contract.
- Homeownership strategy community engagement sessions, cohosted with Barbara Lee (Mayor), are set for December 5 and 7.
- Staff plan to bring the proposed city-county terms for the remaining lead settlement funds, the lead hazard abatement program design, and the inspection program launch plan to the council in the first half of 2027. The county terms also need Board of Supervisors approval.
- Planning and Building will bring proposed fees for the proactive rental inspection program to the council after the county negotiation ends. Community engagement on the program may start as early as next month.
- HCD plans to competitively reprocure all contracted RAP representation services. Staff said the current contracts expire in 2027 and procurement would start in the first half of 2027.
- HCD said its fiscal year 2027-28 scope of work and budget will include a contingency plan for emergency displacement.
Write to the Community and Economic Development Committee before its next meeting: its comment form