· 7 items
City Council, Tuesday, November 10
On the episode: Data center pause extended; split vote on executive search contracts
Corrected . A speaker heard in one of the page's highlights, whom the page gave no role, was given the role of a councilmember. What changed
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Tuesday, November 10
7 items
Agenda changes: one-minute speaker limit and Ethics Commission resolution pulled Item 3
Ethics and meeting rules
At the start of the meeting the presiding officer cut public speaking time to one minute, citing a near lack of quorum, and pulled item 6.26, a resolution marking the Public Ethics Commission's 30th anniversary, from the consent calendar to be brought back later. 00:06:48
- The council president withdrew consent item 6.26 (30th anniversary of the Public Ethics Commission), to be rescheduled. Result: withdrawn. 00:07:08
- The council president set public speaking time at one minute, saying the council was close to losing its quorum 00:06:34
Data center moratorium: 35-day report and ten-month extension Item 4.1
Zoning and plansPollutionEnergy
The council had adopted a 45-day emergency moratorium (Interim Emergency Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S.) on approving any land use entitlements or agreements for developing or operating data centers in Oakland. Staff said it was adopted October 6 and would expire November 20. State law (Government Code 65858(d)) requires a written report within 35 days on steps taken; the council held a public hearing on that report and on an emergency ordinance (file 27-0178) extending the moratorium for ten months and fifteen days, which under the City Charter could be adopted the same day but needed seven votes. Staff said the extension would carry the work through October 5, 2027, while it drafts zoning rules covering where data centers could go and limits on power, water and air quality. 00:07:58
▶ Hear it Where should Oakland draw the line on data centers? · 0:53
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to open the public hearing. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:08:20Ayes: Noel Gallo, Janani Ramachandran, Zac Unger, Carroll Fife, Kevin Jenkins, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Carroll Fife, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to close the public hearing and adopt both pieces of legislation: the resolution issuing the 35-day report, and the emergency ordinance extending the data center moratorium for ten months and fifteen days. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:32:20Ayes: Noel Gallo, Janani Ramachandran, Zac Unger, Carroll Fife, Kevin Jenkins, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Carroll Fife, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
- City staff explained that state law requires a 35-day report on the work done under the 45-day moratorium 00:10:16
- City staff said the 45-day moratorium was adopted October 6 and expires November 20 00:11:20
- City staff cited other cities with data center moratoriums, including San Francisco, Gilroy, Oakley, El Monte and Richmond, and said Richmond adopted a 22.5-month extension 00:13:26
- City staff said staff is consulting utilities and regulators, including PG&E and the air quality district, with particular concern about backup generators 00:16:34
- City staff said the city plans to hire outside consultants because of the expertise this facility type requires 00:17:37
- City staff asked for the ten-month, fifteen-day extension allowed by state law, saying it would carry the work through October 5, 2027 00:19:43
- A councilmember said two major tech companies have leased space in West Oakland and another has shown interest in a downtown site 00:20:38
- A councilmember said the moratorium is not a rejection of technology or economic growth but guardrails on the industry 00:21:39
- A councilmember objected to companies requiring officials and landlords to sign nondisclosure agreements, which keeps the public uninformed 00:22:44
- A councilmember cited public health data showing West Oakland life expectancy six to seven and a half years below the county average 00:23:46
- A councilmember asked staff for a list of land and properties available for development in Oakland 00:26:32
- A councilmember said the city pays to lease space for police and public works, citing $4 million a year near the Coliseum, while public land goes unused 00:27:33
- The council president asked staff to send the council a supplemental list of properties that might be available 00:28:28
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked which city departments will help with the regulatory research 00:29:08
- City staff named economic development, race and equity, and information technology, plus public works and transportation 00:29:44
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for an implementation timeline, such as choosing consultants within 90 days 00:30:43
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for a report back within 30 days on the community engagement plan, regulatory research and consultant procurement 00:32:03
- City staff offered to set up regular updates with the department 00:32:26
- City staff said the project website should be updated before the end of the year 00:33:08
- A councilmember urged that the definition of a data center not end up restricting light manufacturing and industrial uses 00:33:19
- A councilmember said massive GPU farms have no place in Oakland 00:33:19
- A councilmember suggested the threshold could rest on wattage, water use, power use or square footage 00:34:22
- City staff said staff is also considering a place-based approach, allowing some facilities in some areas and not others 00:34:39
- A councilmember thanked a community group that surveyed more than 400 West Oakland residents and shared its data 00:35:18
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said cannabis operations in his district haven't been monitored, and asked who will enforce the moratorium and regulations 00:39:13
- City staff said Planning and Building will lead enforcement and may lean on other departments such as fire 00:40:05
Executive recruitment firm contracts extended, with $75,000 more for one firm Item 5.1
Contracts and purchasingPublic employees
The city uses three outside executive search firms (Ralph Andersen & Associates, The Hawkins Company, and CPS HR Consulting) to recruit senior leaders. As posted, the item would extend all three contracts through August 31, 2027, add $200,000 to Ralph Andersen (from $250,000 to $450,000) and $100,000 to Hawkins (from $250,000 to $350,000), and waive competitive bidding and local/small business requirements (agenda). The Finance and Management Committee had cut the increases to $75,000 for Ralph Andersen only, and staff brought that reduced version to the council. Staff said the money would finish recruitments already under way, including for constitutional policing, and a search for a permanent city administrator. 01:32:20
▶ Hear it A no vote on executive search contracts turns to yes · 0:55
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve the staff recommendation as presented: extend all three executive search contracts and add $75,000 to the Ralph Andersen & Associates contract. Result: passed, 5-2, 1 abstention. No: Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee). Abstained: Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee). 01:52:01Ayes: Zac Unger, Kevin Jenkins, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Noes: Noel Gallo, Janani Ramachandran. Abstained: Carroll Fife. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the city will start a new request for proposals for executive search firms and temporary services 01:35:03
- A councilmember confirmed with staff that the request reflects the committee's cut from $200,000 to $75,000, then moved approval 01:35:29
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said her committee no vote is why the item was on non-consent, and that she opposes any increase to the Ralph Andersen contract 01:36:03
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) argued the city spends too much on headhunting firms and often gets poor results 01:36:03
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said HR staff can recruit in house, and objected that the firms are not local small businesses 01:37:05
- A councilmember argued the city should train and promote its own employees into leadership instead of hiring from outside 01:38:50
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said at first he would also vote no, citing the waiver and the firms not being local 01:42:42
- City staff said the contract is needed to finish the constitutional policing recruitment and the Mayor's priority recruitment 01:43:03
- City staff apologized for the administration for not bringing the request in a timely and transparent way 01:43:50
- City staff said the Mayor wants a professional search firm to recruit the city administrator 01:44:51
- City staff said staff will return to move some of the Hawkins contract authority to Ralph Andersen at no added cost 01:44:51
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the assistant city administrator's explanation led him to change his vote to yes 01:46:00
- City staff said Measure EE created a new council office whose chief would likely be recruited through a search firm 01:47:28
- City staff listed the recruitments: Head Start program director, Human Services director, Constitutional Policing administrator, and Budget administrator 01:48:46
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) urged the same effort and money go to entry-level hiring, such as Head Start teachers she said earn barely $18 an hour 01:50:12
Kenilworth Road subdivision: improvement agreement, encroachment permit, parcel map Item 5.2
Development projects
Three resolutions (files 27-0109, 27-0110, 27-0111) for a hillside development on Kenilworth Road in District 4: an agreement with Kenilworth Property, LLC to build the road, utilities and an emergency fire access path to Devon Way; a revocable permit letting privately owned retaining walls, a pressurized sewer, storm drains and planters sit in the public right-of-way; and conditional approval of Parcel Map 8228 for four lots plus a remainder parcel. Staff said the project, first approved in 2006, is seven single-family homes and the work must finish within two years, backed by bonds. 01:52:27
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve the staff recommendation, all three resolutions. Result: passed, 8-0. 02:03:06Ayes: Noel Gallo, Janani Ramachandran, Zac Unger, Carroll Fife, Kevin Jenkins, Ken Houston, Rowena Brown, Charlene Wang. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the project is seven single-family homes on an unimproved stretch of Kenilworth Road, first approved in 2006 01:53:28
- City staff said the improvements include the roadway, utilities and an emergency fire access path to Devon Way 01:53:28
- City staff said the work must be done within two years, backed by surety bonds at 175% of estimated cost, totaling $552,000 01:54:31
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) supported the project and noted delays from unexpected problems, including a very large mudslide 01:55:57
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said the developer plans biweekly meetings with neighbors on noise, debris and dust, and her office will monitor them 01:55:57
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said neighbors raised air-quality concerns in committee, but he would defer to the district councilmember 02:02:28
Consent calendar, including the Garfield Park sale to OUSD Item 6
Parks and treesSchools and education
The council approved 32 consent items in one vote, with 6.26 withdrawn. They included final passage of several ordinances (SB 79 zoning amendments, waste disposal rules, higher nuisance penalties, the San Leandro Creek Trail license, affordable housing trust fund uses), renewal of the local emergencies on HIV/AIDS, medical cannabis and homelessness, grants and contracts, and the first reading of an ordinance selling the city's 0.6-acre part of Garfield Park to Oakland Unified for $597,500 less closing costs (agenda). 02:03:35
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve the consent calendar as amended, with item 6.26 withdrawn and Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7)'s no on item 6.20 recorded. Result: passed, 8-0. 02:42:23
- Item 6.20, introduction of the ordinance selling the city-owned portion of Garfield Park to Oakland Unified, approved within the consent vote with Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) recorded as no. Result: passed. No: Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7). 02:42:23
- The council president said item 6.26, honoring the Public Ethics Commission, will return in December when the commission's director and chair can attend 02:07:50
- The council president asked the city administrator to have someone help a speaker contesting a parking ticket issued during a council meeting 02:15:32
- City staff said they would work with the speaker and the finance department on the parking citation 02:15:44
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) registered a no vote on the Garfield Park sale, arguing land is more valuable than money and proposing a land swap with OUSD 02:39:15
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) objected that the sale trades land for money going into the general fund 02:40:00
- The council president suggested raising city–school district land questions with the Education Partnership Committee 02:40:46
Council announcements Item 7
Councilmembers announced upcoming community events, and congratulations were offered to two councilmembers on their reelection. 02:42:58
- A councilmember announced a virtual community conversation on homeownership, held with the Housing and Community Development Department, on Monday the 16th from 6 to 7:30 p.m. 02:43:06
- A councilmember announced a free holiday event at the Oakland stadium on December 13, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., with youth baseball training and toy and food giveaways 02:43:54
- The council president congratulated Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) and Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) on their reelection 02:46:17
Adjourning in memory of a homeless advocate
The meeting was adjourned in memory of a Black homeless advocate who died in September and was a regular at council meetings. 02:44:54
Public comment
- Data center moratorium (item 4.1): about 34 people spoke. Roughly 30 urged the council to extend the moratorium, and about ten said the city should eventually ban data centers permanently. Common reasons were West Oakland's pollution and health disparities, higher electricity and water bills, diesel backup generators, noise, and doubts about local jobs. Representatives of a community group said they knocked on about 2,500 doors and conducted 424 surveys, and that 73% of respondents backed a permanent ban. A building trades council representative supported taking the time to set rules. Several speakers asked staff to make sure a secondary-use exemption can't be used to bring in large data centers. One remote speaker proposed limits on water use, noise, and power, and banning diesel backup generators.
- Data center moratorium (item 4.1): about four speakers favored allowing data centers, citing jobs, growth, and job training; one called the staff study a waste of time and money. One person who had not turned in a speaker card was removed by security after two warnings from the chair.
- Executive recruitment contracts (item 5.1): two speakers. One praised the finance committee for scrutinizing and cutting the contracts. The other objected to waiving the competitive process and paying outside firms.
- Kenilworth Road subdivision (item 5.2): four speakers. The property owners, their permitting consultant, and their owner's representative described years of delays. The representative said the project is about 80% complete and should finish by early 2028. A regular speaker objected to the item being moved to non-consent after neighbor complaints and urged approval.
- Consent calendar: about a dozen speakers. Two criticized the City Administrator contract authority report (6.11) for not coming to the council for three years. One complained about parking tickets issued to people attending council meetings. One asked how the cannabis enforcement grant (6.17) would be used, and another called it a continuation of the drug war. One criticized the homelessness emergency declaration alongside encampment sweeps. One objected to the grant to the Catholic bishop (6.33), while two supported the Guadalupe pilgrimage. Two members of a North Oakland neighborhood association said code enforcement had failed for years against a warehousing business that they said owes about $2 million in uncollected fines and fees; one thanked the sponsor of the higher nuisance penalties (6.7).
- Open forum: about 13 speakers, many with La Clinica's Safe Homes initiative, ACE Oakland, and an asthma prevention group, urged the city to launch a lead abatement program and a proactive rental inspection program. One said that seven years after a lead paint settlement Oakland has remediated zero units, while Los Angeles County has remediated more than 1,400. ACE's director said the group helped tenants file over 200 code enforcement complaints in three months with no results.
- Open forum: two speakers raised ICE activity and Oakland's sanctuary city status. A small business owner objected to the litter assessment fee. A U.S. Small Business Administration representative announced a disaster loan center at the Melrose Branch Library for people affected by the September 25 Bancroft apartment fire, open through Friday, November 20. A regular speaker said they plan to appeal a court case over a special election ballot measure.
What's next
- Data center moratorium: the extension runs ten months and fifteen days; staff said the zoning work would continue through October 5, 2027, with community outreach, consultant hiring, a Planning Commission hearing, and council committee review before new rules come back.
- Data center moratorium: Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked for an implementation timeline and updates within 30 days; staff said the project website would be updated before the end of the year; Kevin Jenkins (Councilmember, District 6; President, City Council; Chair, Rules and Legislation Committee) asked staff for a supplemental list of city land available for development, which Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) had raised.
- Item 6.26, the resolution celebrating the Public Ethics Commission's 30th anniversary, is to return in December.
- Item 6.20, the Garfield Park sale ordinance, is scheduled for final passage on December 1, 2026 (agenda).
- Public hearings on the Montclair and Rockridge business improvement district assessments are set for December 1, 2026 (agenda).
- Executive recruitment: HR said it will start a new request for proposals for executive search firms and temporary services, and staff said it will return to move some of the Hawkins contract authority to Ralph Andersen at no added cost.
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said he will raise the idea of land swaps with Oakland Unified again; the suggestion was to take it up in the Education Partnership Committee.
- Kenilworth Road: construction is to resume in the spring with biweekly neighbor meetings; the owner's representative said completion is expected by early 2028.
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) said she will bring a resolution honoring the homeless advocate in whose memory the meeting was adjourned.
- The city administrator's office said it will work with the finance department on parking tickets issued to people attending council meetings.
- Events announced: a virtual homeownership conversation on Monday, November 16, 6–7:30 p.m.; a free holiday event at the Oakland stadium on December 13, 11 a.m.–4 p.m.; an SBA disaster loan center for Bancroft fire survivors open through November 20.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form