· 4 items
Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, October 27
On the episode: Committee backs $75,000 for executive searches; Garfield Park sale advances
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Public Works and Transportation Committee Tuesday, October 27
4 items
Approval of draft minutes from October 13, 2026 Item 1
Routine approval of the committee's draft minutes from its October 13, 2026 meeting. 00:01:42
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve the minutes. Result: passed, 3-0, 1 excused. 00:02:33Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
Pending list of outstanding committee items Item 2
The committee's schedule of outstanding items, its list of reports and items waiting to be scheduled. No changes were made. 00:02:56
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to accept the pending list as is. Result: passed, 3-0, 1 excused. 00:06:21Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's record
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked when the parking division reorganization report would be scheduled, noting the list shows no specific date 00:06:07
Kenilworth Road subdivision: improvement agreement, encroachment permit and Parcel Map 8228 Item 3
Development projectsPollution
Three resolutions for a hillside subdivision on Kenilworth Road (in District 4, per staff) owned by Kenilworth Property, LLC: (1) a subdivision improvement agreement letting the owner defer building required public infrastructure as a condition of approving Parcel Map No. 8228; (2) conditional, revocable major encroachment permit ENMJ22054 allowing privately owned retaining walls, a pressurized sanitary sewer, storm drains, bioretention planters and irrigation under and next to Kenilworth Road; and (3) conditional approval of Parcel Map No. 8228 for a four-lot subdivision with a remainder parcel, a right-of-way dedication and a sewer reserve abandonment (agenda). Staff described the overall project as seven single-family homes on vacant downhill parcels along an unpaved stretch of the road. City staff said that without the agreement the map would expire and the owner would have to restart the entitlement process. Neighbors who spoke described years of dust, diesel fumes and noise from the site. 00:06:38
▶ Hear it Does this agreement give a developer more time? · 0:31
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to approve all three resolutions and forward them to the November 10 special City Council meeting on non-consent. Result: passed, 3-0, 1 abstention. Abstained: Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7). 00:40:36Ayes: Zac Unger, Charlene Wang, Noel Gallo. Abstained: Ken Houston. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
- City staff presented the project as seven single-family homes on vacant downhill parcels along an unpaved part of Kenilworth Road 00:08:30
- City staff said the project was first approved in 2010, with later extensions from the Planning Commission and Planning Bureau 00:08:30
- City staff said the agreement requires a secondary emergency fire access route to Devon Way and financial security of 175 percent of estimated construction cost 00:09:30
- City staff said the private infrastructure would pass to a Geologic Hazard Abatement District and a homeowners association once they are formed 00:10:38
- City staff said the resolutions have no fiscal impact, because the subdivider pays permit fees that cover staff costs 00:11:38
- The committee chair said he generally supports new homes but they must follow all applicable codes, and that his staffer would follow up with the neighbors 00:22:02
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) said the project isn't in his district and he would abstain until he could talk with the District 4 councilmember 00:22:30
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said she had seconded the motion before hearing public comment and realizing the item was controversial, and asked what the deferral request meant 00:23:10
- City staff explained that the agreement lets the developer record the final map before finishing public improvements, backed by bonds the city can call if the work isn't done 00:25:13
- City staff said the agreement sets a deadline for the improvements, which he believed was two years with possible extensions by the city engineer 00:25:13
- City staff confirmed the agreement gives the developer more time, and said that without it the map would expire and entitlements would start over 00:26:01
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked what community meetings the contractor had held with residents 00:26:37
- City staff said community engagement normally happens during planning entitlements, and the transportation department did none for the permitting or the map 00:27:47
- An applicant representative blamed the delays on an ancient landslide more than 40 feet deep, which forced a redesign about six years ago 00:30:21
- An applicant representative said COVID-era inspection delays let the permits expire, and renewing them took about two years 00:30:21
- An applicant representative said the project was approved in 2006 with about eight pages of conditions, including on dust and noise, and offered to meet with neighbors 00:34:51
- An applicant representative argued that retaining walls and grading are already in place, so the project won't go away if it isn't approved 00:35:57
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked to see the contractor's dust control plan, from both the city and the contractor 00:37:19
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) asked the neighbors whether they had reported problems to the city or code compliance in writing 00:37:19
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) urged the parties to meet and try to resolve the issues before the next meeting 00:38:43
- The committee chair proposed sending the item to the full council on non-consent so the District 4 councilmember can meet both sides and weigh in, and offered to help mediate 00:39:37
$5 million construction management contract for Broadway Streetscape project Item 4
Streets and public worksPublic transitStreet safety
A resolution awarding a $5,000,000 professional services agreement to VSCE, Inc. for construction management support on the Broadway Streetscape Improvements Project (Project No. 1008515), with CEQA findings. Staff said the council awarded the construction contract to McGuire and Hester in July 2026. The work covers pedestrian and crossing improvements, lighting, red bus-only lanes, transit shelters, street trees and upgraded signals on Broadway from 2nd to 11th Street and from 20th Street to Grand Avenue. Staff said the contract is fully grant-funded and that VSCE is an Oakland-certified local business. 00:41:04
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve the resolution and forward it to the November 10 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:55:11Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Charlene Wang, Noel Gallo. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the council awarded the construction contract for the project to McGuire and Hester in July 2026 00:41:38
- City staff described the project limits as Broadway from 2nd to 11th Street and from 20th Street to Grand Avenue 00:41:38
- City staff said VSCE will do 60 percent of the work itself, and the $5 million contract is fully funded by state and local grants 00:42:39
- City staff said the city issued its request for proposals on July 31 and received two proposals in mid-August, with VSCE scoring highest 00:42:39
- The committee chair said this is the second large outside engineering contract recently, hoped to bring the work in-house, and said the city contracts out because it has trouble hiring 00:43:31
- City staff said he did not have the exact breakdown of the remaining 40 percent, which goes to specialty subconsultants 00:44:30
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) praised the local small-business selection and asked whether the remaining 40 percent would also go to Oakland small businesses 00:44:51
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) noted the project is in District 2, questioned the cost of oversight work, and asked how many staff the firm would assign 00:45:35
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked whether it is typical for construction management to cost about a quarter of construction costs 00:46:52
- City staff said the contract covers resident engineers, office engineers, inspectors, special inspections, materials testing and environmental monitoring for federal requirements 00:47:00
- City staff explained that firms are ranked on qualifications first and fee proposals are opened afterward, with no budget set by the city 00:49:07
- City staff answering a councilmember, said the engineer's estimate for the management services was about $4 million 00:49:34
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said she would vote yes but called the documentation too thin for a contract this size and asked for more information before the full council 00:54:30
Public comment
- Item 2 (pending list): one speaker asked the city to review tree-removal permitting. They said the permit fee, in the 600-dollar range, isn't refunded if removal is denied, that investigations take six to eight weeks, and that there is no emergency process when trees threaten sewer lines.
- Item 3 (Kenilworth Road): four members of the public spoke. Two neighbors living just above the site described years of dust, diesel fumes, noise and little progress; one of them objected to giving the owner more time. One of them said under questioning that he had not complained to the city in writing. One speaker asked for sidewalks, transportation planning, paving on Grizzly Peak Boulevard and fire evacuation routes. One raised the costs owners would carry for the hazard district and HOA, and the nearly 20-year delay. Two representatives of the applicant also spoke in support.
- Item 4 (Broadway Streetscape): two speakers. One supported the project and asked for a bike turn box at Broadway and 6th Street. The other asked about the status of many East Oakland transportation and capital projects and called for fairer prioritization, saying Chinatown and downtown get more attention than East Oakland.
- Open forum: two speakers. One said the report on the City Administrator's spending of up to $250,000 should go to each affected committee, not just Finance, and cited public works spending such as tree maintenance and boarding up city property. The other thanked Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) for raising the parking reorganization report and said they looked forward to upcoming transportation reports.
What's next
- Item 3 (Kenilworth Road resolutions) goes to the November 10 special City Council meeting on non-consent, so the District 4 councilmember can weigh in.
- Item 4 (VSCE $5,000,000 contract) goes to the November 10 City Council agenda on consent.
- Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) asked staff to provide fuller documentation on the services in the VSCE contract before it reaches the full council.
- A councilmember asked for the subcontractor breakdown of the remaining 40% of the VSCE contract, and whether it goes to Oakland small businesses.
- A councilmember asked for the Kenilworth contractor's dust control plan from both the city and the contractor, and urged the applicant and neighbors to meet before the next meeting. The committee chair offered to sit down with both parties, and said his staffer would contact the neighbors.
- The parking division reorganization report is still on the pending list with no specific date. When asked, no date was given at the meeting.
Write to the Public Works and Transportation Committee before its next meeting: its comment form