CivicFM
Oakland

· 7 items

Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, October 27

On the episode: Committee backs $75,000 for executive searches; Garfield Park sale advances

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Finance and Management Committee Tuesday, October 27

7 items

The recording · Agenda

Schedule of outstanding committee items Item 2

The committee's routine review of its list of pending and scheduled items, including recurring quarterly and annual reports. This was a special meeting, so there were no minutes to approve. 00:05:22

  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to accept the determination of schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:06:27Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record

City Administrator contract authority report, FY 2023-24 through 2025-26 Item 3

Contracts and purchasing

An informational report listing purchases and contracts the City Administrator signed without council approval, under the authority the Municipal Code gives for contracts up to $250,000. The reports for FY 2023-24 and 2024-25 came late; staff said this version is more complete than earlier ones, adding grant and cooperative agreements. It shows the contracts the City Administrator awarded without a council vote; staff stressed the amounts are awards, not spending. 00:06:49

  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to forward the report to the November 10 special City Council agenda, on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:48:22Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
  • City staff explained that the report covers construction, professional services, grant agreements and purchase orders under the City Administrator's authority up to $250,000 00:07:16
  • City staff said the FY 2023-24 and 2024-25 reports were delayed by a change in leadership and in who handled compliance oversight in Finance, and committed to bringing the report every fall 00:09:19
  • The committee chair disputed the explanation that a cancelled June meeting caused the delay, noting the committee did meet in June and the gap covered three years 00:11:01
  • City staff said the 2024-25 report was delayed partly by budget rebalancing at the end of 2025 and was overlooked 00:13:00
  • City staff said the report is more comprehensive than earlier versions, adding grant and cooperative agreements that had not been included before 00:13:00
  • A councilmember asked whether $250,000 is the right threshold for the City Administrator's contract authority 00:15:34
  • City staff said the limit was raised from $100,000 to $250,000 around 2013, has not kept up with inflation since, and suggested a more nuanced limit that accounts for contract length 00:15:49
  • A councilmember asked that future reports show which fund pays for each contract, citing a $26,000 police traffic-control contract for Juneteenth 2026 00:18:33
  • A councilmember called it a red flag that one vendor can receive more than $250,000 in a year without council review, and said such cases should come to council automatically 00:19:33
  • City staff said one vendor can hold several contracts for different services, but if one service goes over $250,000 the department must bring it to council 00:20:08
  • A councilmember pointed to a $400,000 information technology contract in the report that exceeds the threshold and asked what decides which contracts skip council 00:22:20
  • City staff explained that contracts under $250,000 often still come to council because the City Administrator cannot waive small local business requirements, which apply above $50,000 00:23:10
  • City staff cautioned that the amounts listed are contract awards, not spending, and that the city's systems cannot easily trace spending and funding sources by contract 00:23:44
  • City staff agreed to provide spending and fund information in future, probably in a different format, and warned that Oracle data tracks vendors, not contract awards 00:25:55
  • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) said other departments describe procurement as a bottleneck, and asked what is being done about racial disparities in small contracts that a disparity study had flagged 00:27:25
  • City staff described a small staff serving the whole city, with a purchasing side of one supervisor and four buyers, against an industry minimum of 12 to 15 00:30:55
  • City staff said some delays happen because the city now enforces council's rules without exceptions, and called this a culture change 00:31:40
  • The committee chair asked about a $244,000 polling contract with EMC Research and whether council authorized it 00:33:30
  • City staff said the polling contract was for possible revenue ballot measures and had not been used 00:34:15
  • City staff said nothing had been spent on the polling contract, it was not used for Measure E, and having a vendor ready in advance is good practice 00:34:44
  • The committee chair asked why only one Laurel safety ambassador grant appears in the report when she knows of several over the years 00:36:15
  • City staff said a contract recorded in the work order portal may not show in Oracle until a purchase order is issued, and promised follow-up 00:38:10
  • The committee chair asked why contracts under the City Administrator's authority totaled about $24 million in each of the first two years but about half that in 2025-26 00:38:33
  • City staff noted that grants the council approved by its own resolution would not appear in this report 00:39:23

Citywide staffing and vacancy report, September 2026 Item 4

Public employees

An informational report from Human Resources on vacancies as of September 15, 2026, hiring timelines, separations, and recruitment outreach. Staff reported a citywide vacancy rate of 17.89%, the lowest in the reporting periods since October 2021. 00:48:49

▶ Hear it Over 700 vacancies, but only about 34 jobs posted · 0:48

  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to receive and file the informational report in committee. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:20:51Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
  • City staff reported the citywide vacancy rate fell from 19.69% in February to 17.89% 00:53:32
  • City staff said the September rate is the lowest of the periods shown, just under a previous low of 17.94% in April 2025 00:53:32
  • City staff reported 368 vacancies with no recruitment activity, down from 431 in February 00:52:31
  • City staff explained that added budgeted positions raised some departments' rates, such as the City Auditor's office, now at 33% 00:54:33
  • City staff said IBEW has the highest vacancy rate of the city's unions, partly because its budgeted positions grew from 17 to 21 00:55:35
  • City staff reported separations fell from 380 in FY 2024-25 to 322 in FY 2025-26 00:56:37
  • City staff said that since FY 2023-24 the city recorded 1,693 new hires and 1,697 separations 00:57:37
  • City staff said in-person new employee orientation will return in 2027 00:58:41
  • City staff said the public safety recruitment team had just filled its last assistant HR analyst position 00:59:26
  • City staff named the departments' own hiring process as the biggest obstacle to faster hiring 01:00:40
  • City staff proposed expanded certification rules, since departments now get only four referrals per position at a time 01:01:35
  • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) noted the HR department's own vacancy rate fell from 44% to 34%, and asked which positions remain open 01:02:26
  • City staff said departments cancelled requisitions they no longer needed, so the count now reflects real need 01:03:50
  • Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee) raised concern about the IBEW hiring timeline of about 287 days and the shortage of electricians for streetlight repair 01:04:47
  • City staff said that figure came from one electrician recruitment, slowed by trouble finding outside assessors to give the exam 01:05:05
  • The committee chair asked why so few jobs are posted on the city website given the number of vacancies 01:05:34
  • City staff said one eligible list can fill multiple positions and that recruitments are opened in priority order 01:06:11
  • City staff said no career fair at City Hall is currently planned, though two staff now coordinate outside career fairs 01:08:15
  • City staff said candidates can now name the departments they want, so referrals are not wasted 01:11:29
  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked what share of applicants fail to meet minimum qualifications 01:12:39
  • City staff said staff review minimum qualifications at the start of each recruitment to remove artificial barriers, and could provide the requested data 01:13:07

NeoGov HR software subscription Item 5

Government technologyPublic employees

A resolution for a cooperative contract with Governmentjobs.com, Inc. (NeoGov) for the city's human resources information system: recruitment, applicant tracking, onboarding, training and performance management. It runs three years, July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2029, with three one-year extensions under Sourcewell Contract No. 030425-PDMS, for up to $3,674,817.80 over six years. Staff had pulled an earlier version to find better pricing. It adds two new modules, for candidate outreach and for background checks. 01:21:11

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the item to the November 10 special City Council agenda, on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:29:12Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
  • City staff said the item was pulled earlier so staff could pursue a cooperative contract with better pricing 01:21:58
  • City staff said the city has used NeoGov for over fifteen years and it connects to the city's Oracle system 01:21:58
  • City staff said the agreement adds two modules funded in the mid-cycle budget, including one that centralizes background investigations for public safety hiring 01:21:58
  • City staff said the first three years cost about $1.67 million and the full six years about $3.67 million, paid from internal service funds 01:23:00
  • City staff told a councilmember the online testing services listed are already in place, not new 01:28:37

Baker Tilly contract to overhaul city purchasing Item 6

Contracts and purchasingSmall business

A resolution for a $249,000 professional services agreement with Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP. The firm would help carry out the 24 recommendations of its 2024 review of city purchasing and contracting. The resolution would waive competitive bidding and local/small local business requirements. Staff said the current rules are complex and can create barriers for small and local businesses. 01:29:37

  • Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the item to the November 10 special City Council agenda, on consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:38:14Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
  • City staff said the earlier Baker Tilly review made 24 recommendations on policies and procedures, organizational structure, and contracting equity 01:30:15
  • City staff said the review found existing requirements can unintentionally create barriers for small and local businesses 01:31:15
  • City staff said the work goes with a new contracting software, Authorium, but that software alone will not fix the systemic problems 01:31:15
  • A councilmember said her main question had been how to move the recommendations into implementation, and that this contract does that 01:34:08

Authorizing the remaining Measure DD, KK and U bonds Item 7

Bonds and debt

An ordinance authorizing the city to borrow and sell its remaining voter-approved general obligation bonds under Measures DD, KK and U, which pay for parks, transportation, housing and other capital projects. Staff described it as an umbrella authorization for about $532 million. Each future sale would still come back to council, and the next is planned for March at up to $275 million. 01:38:41

  • Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), to approve the staff recommendation and forward the ordinance to the December 1 City Council agenda, non-consent. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:51:21Ayes: Janani Ramachandran, Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Charlene Wang. From the clerk's record
  • City staff said the ordinance authorizes the rest of the bonds across all three measures, with each sale still coming to council 01:38:58
  • City staff said the next sale is planned for March at up to $275 million, and bond counsel advised the first reading be at the December 1 regular meeting, not the November 10 special meeting 01:38:58
  • City staff said sale sizes depend on department needs, the last sale was about $334 million, and tax-exempt bond money must be spent within three years 01:40:20
  • The committee chair cited the remaining amounts under each measure and asked about the plan for the rest 01:40:47
  • City staff said the rest would likely be sold within another year to year and a half, depending on how fast departments can spend 01:41:16
  • City staff expected transportation, housing and parks money to be fully used by the next two-year budget, but not the full authorization for police facilities 01:41:56
  • The committee chair said Measure KK money should be spent down first before the city asks voters for a successor measure 01:43:27
  • A councilmember asked why only $6 million of the remaining Measure DD money would be sold, citing community questions about Estuary Park redevelopment in her district 01:49:40
  • City staff said parks projects under KK and U are fully allocated, and bonds won't be sold until projects are ready to start because of the three-year spending window 01:50:29

Executive recruitment contracts: request for added money cut from $300,000 to $75,000 Item 8

Appointments and leadershipPublic employees

As posted, the resolution would extend three executive search contracts through August 31, 2027 and add $300,000 in total. Ralph Andersen & Associates would go up $200,000, from $250,000 to $450,000. The Hawkins Company would go up $100,000, from $250,000 to $350,000. CPS HR Consulting would get an extension only. Competitive bidding and local business requirements would be waived. The firms recruit for the city's top jobs, including the City Administrator search. Staff cut its request to $75,000, all for Ralph Andersen, and the committee voted 3-1, with Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) voting no, to recommend the extensions with only that added money. The item goes to the November 10 special City Council meeting, off consent. 01:51:47

▶ Hear it An executive search request shrinks from $300,000 to $75,000 · 0:55

  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee), to extend each of the three agreements through August 31, 2027 with no increase in amount, keeping the requested waivers. Result: withdrawn. 02:11:34
  • Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve as amended and forward to the November 10 City Council agenda: extend each of the three agreements through August 31, 2027, with no increase except $75,000 to Ralph Andersen & Associates. Result: passed, 3-1. No: Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee). 02:11:55Ayes: Charlene Wang, Rowena Brown, Zac Unger. Noes: Janani Ramachandran. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
  • City staff said the extensions would keep the firms available while HR prepares a new request for proposals by the end of the calendar year, with departments paying the fees 01:53:44
  • City staff listed the recruitments the added money would support 01:53:44
  • The committee chair opposed the extensions, citing the cost of executive searches and budget uncertainty, and said the city often hires someone it picked from the start 01:54:03
  • A councilmember called the increase too large, said a recent recruitment for a position in his office drew about 220 applications without a search firm, and noted uncertainty over Measure EE and a possible mayor's office restructuring 01:55:05
  • A councilmember asked why the city doesn't promote more from within instead of hiring outside recruiters 01:56:02
  • City staff said only about $14,000 remains on the contract, not enough for the City Administrator recruitment and others in progress 01:58:49
  • City staff said the mayor's office knew about the item and supported at least the Ralph Andersen increase 01:59:11
  • A councilmember invited the mayor's office to come back with a proposal for a smaller amount 02:00:09
  • City staff asked whether the committee would approve extending only the contract terms, through August 2027 02:04:57
  • City staff asked whether a smaller increase would be acceptable so staff can finish current recruitments and pay their bills 02:06:02
  • The committee chair said she would not support any increase but was open to extending the term to August 2027 02:06:53
  • City staff said money already spent on the contracts went to earlier recruitments, not the ones now listed 02:07:18
  • City staff said Ralph Andersen bid on the City Administrator recruitment, and that staff believed the mayor's office had selected it 02:08:45
  • City staff reduced the request to $75,000 for Ralph Andersen, for the City Administrator recruitment and the rest of the constitutional policing administrator recruitment 02:09:28

Public comment

  • Item 2: two people signed up. One waived her time; the transcript doesn't clearly show whether the other spoke.
  • Item 3 (contract authority report): three speakers. One said the council's pending list showed this report as given on February 24, 2026, and urged better tracking of annual reports. One said the report should be semiannual and questioned specific entries, such as police protective gear and $1 vending contracts. One tied the item to organizing city government under a possible strong-mayor system and an IBA position.
  • Item 4 (staffing report): three speakers. One raised hiring of Black Americans, how few city employees live in Oakland, and employees' legal status. One welcomed the progress and parking enforcement hiring, and urged HR to follow up before eligible lists expire. One opposed cutting worker health and retirement benefits and suggested a small pay cut instead.
  • Item 5 (NeoGov): two speakers. One objected that the July 1 start date had already passed, and questioned the extension options and the diversity language. One noted San Diego is negotiating the same contract and asked whether there are problems with the vendor.
  • Item 6 (Baker Tilly): two speakers. One supported the effort but asked about costs, racial equity, and a review of the $250,000 limit, and also criticized how the race and ethnicity categories were listed in the NeoGov item's materials. One urged applying ideals of tech accountability to procurement.
  • Item 7 (bonds): three speakers. One said bond money is not distributed fairly across neighborhoods and that parks sit unused. One thanked staff for resuming bond sales after a year without them, which he linked to stalled street paving, and asked that any future decision to skip a sale be announced to council. One spoke on middle-income housing before the connection dropped.
  • Item 8 (executive recruitment): two speakers. One urged against moving forward until the Measure EE outcome is known, and questioned the firms' track record. One suggested scrutinizing upper-management positions to save money.
  • Open forum: three speakers. One repeated the concern about the pending list for the contract authority report. One said money from a planned sale of Garfield Park land, about $500,000 headed to the general fund, may legally have to go to replacement park facilities. One spoke about the upcoming IBA measure and a chief operating officer model.

What's next

  • November 10 special City Council meeting: the contract authority report (item 3), the NeoGov contract for up to $3,674,817.80 (item 5), and the $249,000 Baker Tilly contract (item 6) are forwarded on consent.
  • November 10 special City Council meeting: the amended executive recruitment contracts (item 8) are forwarded on non-consent after the 3-1 vote. The amendment would extend all three contracts through August 31, 2027 and add only $75,000, to Ralph Andersen & Associates.
  • December 1 regular City Council meeting: the bond ordinance for Measures DD, KK and U (item 7) is forwarded for first reading on non-consent. The next bond sale is planned for March at up to $275 million (per staff), and each sale will come back to council separately.
  • Staff committed to bringing the contract authority report every fall; next year's covers FY 2026-27. Staff said it will try to add spending and fund-source information, possibly in a different format.
  • Finance staff promised to follow up with Economic & Workforce Development, possibly by email, on why only one Laurel safety ambassador grant appears in the report.
  • HR said it will issue a new request for proposals for executive recruitment services by the end of the calendar year.
  • HR said it could provide data on how many applicants fail minimum qualifications. Asked whether staff moved from Transportation to Finance account for Finance's staffing numbers, staff said it was likely but would need to check each position; a councilmember asked for follow-up, but HR made no firm commitment.
  • HR said it is in talks with labor groups on changing civil service rules to allow more referrals per vacancy.
  • In-person new employee orientation is to return in 2027.

Write to the Finance and Management Committee before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error