· 13 items
Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, October 15
On the episode: Committee backs shorter parking contract extension; capital audit and housing bonds head to council
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Rules and Legislation Committee Thursday, October 15
13 items
Committee pending list Item 2
The committee's routine review of the schedule of outstanding committee items, also called the pending list. The clerk said no public speakers had signed up for it. It was approved without changes. 00:01:39
- Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) seconded, to approve item 2 as is. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:02:06Ayes: Rowena Brown, Carroll Fife, Kevin Jenkins. Absent: Janani Ramachandran. Moved by Carroll Fife, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
Grant to remove surrendered and abandoned boats Item 3.1
Federal and state fundingPollutionContracts and purchasing
Oakland Police Department request to accept the FY 2026-2027 Surrendered and Abandoned Vessel Exchange (SAVE) grant: $75,000 for removing abandoned boats, a 10% in-kind staff match of $7,500, and a $12,180 General Purpose Fund contribution for central services. It would also waive competitive bidding and local/small local business requirements so the city can hire specialized vendors to remove, store and dispose of abandoned vessels as needed. Using an urgency finding (Rule 24), it was scheduled for the October 20 City Council consent calendar. The urgency finding says the grant term began October 1 and the work has sped up ahead of El Niño storms, for which the governor has declared a state of emergency. It was approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:02:06
- The city clerk read the urgency finding into the record: the grant term began October 1 and the department wants the money approved quickly so boats can be removed before the storms 00:03:08
Baker Tilly procurement consulting contract (title change) Item 3.2
Contracts and purchasing
Finance Department proposal for a professional services contract of up to $249,000 (agenda) with Baker Tilly to help improve the city's procurement, purchasing and contracting. It would waive the competitive RFP/Q and local/small local business requirements. The title change names the contractor as Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP rather than Baker Tilly US, LLP. It was scheduled for the October 27 Finance and Management Committee and approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:04:09
- The city clerk read in the new title and short title, which change the contracting entity to Baker Tilly Advisory Group LP 00:04:09
Extending executive recruitment firm contracts (title change) Item 3.3
Appointments and leadershipContracts and purchasing
Human Resources request to amend the city's contracts with three executive search firms and extend all three through August 31, 2027. Ralph Andersen & Associates would go from $250,000 to $450,000 and The Hawkins Company from $250,000 to $350,000 (agenda amounts); CPS HR Consulting would get the extension only. The title change read at the meeting adds a waiver of the competitive RFP/Q and local/small business requirements, which the printed agenda title doesn't include. It was scheduled for the October 27 Finance and Management Committee and approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:05:09
Report on the city's cannabis program (title change) Item 3.4
Cannabis
Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) requested an informational report on the city's cannabis regulatory program covering everything since it began: permitting, taxes and revenues, equity program compliance, workforce outcomes, staffing, fees, public-safety coordination, enforcement, reporting to other governments, and how cannabis revenue has been spent. The new title read at the meeting asks for the report from the City Administrator and sets it for the November 17 Community and Economic Development Committee. It was approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:06:49
Sale of part of Garfield Park to OUSD (title change) Item 3.5
Parks and treesSchools and education
Parks, Recreation and Youth Development proposal for an ordinance to sell the city-owned 0.6-acre portion of Garfield Park at 2201-2299 East 17th Street to Oakland Unified for $597,500, less closing costs, so the district can renovate the Garfield Elementary campus. It would also approve an agreement letting the city and the community use the athletic field on the renovated campus, declare the land exempt surplus land, and adopt CEQA findings. The title change regroups the clauses. It was scheduled for the October 27 Life Enrichment Committee and approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:08:19
- The city clerk read in the new title for the sale of the city's portion of the park to the school district 00:08:19
2027 meeting calendar and a Rent Board appointment Item 3.6, 3.7
Appointments and leadershipRenters and tenants
Two items were set for the October 29 Rules and Legislation Committee. The first is the City Clerk's draft 2027 calendar for City Council and committee meetings and report distribution. The second is a resolution confirming Barbara Lee (Mayor)'s appointment of an undesignated representative to the Housing, Residential Rent and Relocation Board. Both were approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:09:24
Firefighter training agreement with Piedmont Item 3.8
Fire and paramedics
Oakland Fire Department request for an agreement with the City of Piedmont on firefighter training, education and cost reimbursement. It was scheduled for the November 10 City Council consent calendar, skipping the Public Safety Committee under Rule 24 so it can be authorized close to the start of the November 2026 fire academy. It was approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:09:24
- The city clerk read the Rule 24 reason: the department wants authorization close to the start of the November 2026 fire academy 00:10:28
Annual anti-displacement and rent program report Item 3.9
Renters and tenants
Housing and Community Development's informational report on anti-displacement programs, including the annual Rent Adjustment Program report, for fiscal year 2025-2026. It was scheduled for the November 17 Community and Economic Development Committee and approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:10:28
Report on clearing vegetation along evacuation routes Item 3.10
Emergency preparednessFire and paramedics
Oakland Fire Department's informational report on its progress clearing vegetation along the city's evacuation routes. It was scheduled for the November 17 Public Safety Committee. Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) was added as a co-sponsor. It was approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:10:28
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) said the member's office had worked with the fire department on the report, and asked to be listed as a co-sponsor 00:11:28
Measure NN violence reduction report at a special joint meeting Item 3.11
Violence preventionPolicingFire and paramedics
An informational report from the Police Department, the Department of Violence Prevention and the Fire Department on reducing violence under Measure NN, the Oakland Community Violence and Emergency Response Act of 2024. It was scheduled for a November 30 special joint meeting of the City Council, the Oakland Public Safety Planning and Oversight Commission, the Community Policing Advisory Board and the Police Commission. City staff said that meeting starts at 12:30 PM. It was approved as part of the single vote on item 3. 00:11:42
Committee recommendations sent to the October 20 City Council Item 3.12-3.27
Affordable housingParkingCode enforcement
Items the October 13 committees forwarded to the October 20 City Council. Unless noted, the agenda amounts weren't spoken at the meeting. On consent: - A Mythics, LLC agreement, extended to November 30, 2028 and increased from $249,850 to $1,250,000. - The Modaxo parking citation system contract, as amended in committee: extended only to June 30, 2027 on the same terms, with direction to return soon with other vendor options, privacy protections against data collection, and payment of the outstanding invoice. The proposal had been through March 31, 2028, up to $5,279,143, including $1,347,328 in outstanding invoices. - A $5,055,898 contract with McGuire and Hester for the East 12th Street Bikeway. - An amendment to Resolution 91091 on state Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities funds for the Residences at Liberation Park, up to $44,661,404. - A $4,000,000 construction management contract with Azad Engineering for the MLK Jr. Way streetscape project. - Ready-mix concrete purchases of up to $4.8 million over four years. - A $3,000,000 EPA grant for PCB cleanup in Arroyo Viejo Creek. - A 25-year San Leandro Creek Trail maintenance license. - The Redevelopment Successor Agency termination plan, in two pieces of legislation. - Up to $50,000,000 in Measure U and other affordable housing funds, with amendments making it contingent on the sale of Tranche 3 bonds. - An Affordable Housing Trust Fund ordinance change. - An $1,563,571 firearm relinquishment reimbursement agreement with the Superior Court. Non-consent: the City Auditor's audit of capital improvement program financial management. Public hearings: - A report on the hotel-tax (TOT) sharing agreement with Oakland Roots and Soul. - Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee)'s ordinance raising nuisance civil penalties to up to $2,500 per day for repeated or continuing violations and $10,000 per day for unabated nuisances, as amended in committee. Continued: the Community Police Review Agency's twice-yearly report, sponsored by Charlene Wang (Councilmember, District 2; Chair, Public Safety Committee), moved to the October 27 Public Safety Committee. The committee then approved all of item 3, as amended, in one vote. 00:12:56
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved, Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) seconded, to approve all of item 3 (items 3.1 through 3.27) as amended. Result: passed, 4-0. 00:20:18
- The city clerk read the committee's amendments to the parking citation contract, which limit the extension to June 30, 2027 and call for other vendor options 00:12:56
- The city clerk noted the capital improvement program audit goes to the October 20 Council as a non-consent item 00:15:03
- The city clerk noted the Roots and Soul hotel-tax sharing report goes to the October 20 Council as a public hearing 00:16:08
- The city clerk read the Measure U amendment making the housing funding contingent on the sale of Tranche 3 bonds 00:16:08
- The city clerk read the nuisance penalty amendment replacing $1,000 with $2,500 00:18:11
- The city clerk noted the police review agency report was continued to the October 27 Public Safety Committee 00:18:11
- A councilmember summarized the changes to item 3 before the vote: title changes on 3.3 and 3.4, and a co-sponsor added to 3.10 00:19:43
Draft agendas and pending lists; October 27 Finance Committee moved to a 9 AM special meeting Item 4
Review of the October 20 City Council agenda, the October 22 Rules agenda, all committee pending lists, the draft October 27 committee agendas and the draft October 29 Rules agenda. The administration had no changes. At Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee)'s request, the October 27 Finance and Management Committee becomes a special meeting starting at 9 AM. 00:20:18
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) seconded, to approve item 4 as amended. Result: passed. 00:21:31
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) asked to make the October 27 Finance Committee a special meeting at 9 AM, saying members had been polled and there was a quorum 00:20:59
- A councilmember noted the special meeting on the 27th starting at 9 AM and called for a motion 00:21:17
Public comment
- Item 3 drew no public comment. The clerk said comment would be taken only at open forum.
- At open forum, three speakers from One Fair Wage urged the council to place a ballot measure raising Oakland's minimum wage to $30 an hour on its agenda. They said enough signatures had been gathered, and one said the City Clerk's office had told them verbally the previous Friday that the signatures were sufficient. They argued state law requires the council to consider a certified measure at its next meeting, and noted it was not on the October 20 Council agenda or the Rules agenda. One suggested the council could order a study of the measure, as they said Alameda County did.
- Two of those speakers framed the measure in terms of dignity and racial equity. One cited the history of the eight-hour workday; another cited tipped workers and the legacy of slavery, and said Black residents gathered most of the signatures.
What's next
- October 20 City Council consent calendar (agenda): the SAVE abandoned-vessel grant; the Mythics extension; the parking citation contract as amended; the East 12th Street Bikeway contract; the Liberation Park funding amendment; the MLK Jr. Way construction management contract; the ready-mix concrete purchases; the EPA Arroyo Viejo Creek grant; the San Leandro Creek Trail license; the Redevelopment Successor Agency termination plan; the Measure U affordable housing funding as amended; the Affordable Housing Trust Fund ordinance; and the firearm relinquishment grant.
- October 20 City Council public hearings: the report on the hotel-tax sharing agreement with Oakland Roots and Soul, and Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee)'s ordinance raising nuisance penalties as amended. Also on October 20, as a non-consent item: the capital improvement program audit.
- October 27 Finance and Management Committee, now a special meeting starting at 9 AM: the Baker Tilly procurement consulting contract and the executive recruitment contract extensions.
- October 27 Life Enrichment Committee: the sale of the city's portion of Garfield Park to OUSD.
- October 27 Public Safety Committee: the continued Community Police Review Agency report.
- October 29 Rules and Legislation Committee: the draft 2027 legislative calendar and the Rent Board appointment.
- November 10 City Council consent calendar: the firefighter training agreement with Piedmont.
- November 17 Community and Economic Development Committee: the cannabis program report and the anti-displacement / Rent Adjustment Program report.
- November 17 Public Safety Committee: the report on vegetation clearing along evacuation routes, now co-sponsored by Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee).
- November 30, 12:30 PM: special joint meeting of the City Council, OPSPOC, the Community Policing Advisory Board and the Police Commission on Measure NN violence reduction.
- Open forum speakers said the $30 minimum wage ballot measure must legally come to the council, and noted it was not on the October 20 agenda. No official responded at the meeting.
Write to the Rules and Legislation Committee before its next meeting: its comment form