· 8 items
Public Works and Transportation Committee, Tuesday, October 13
On the episode: Committee backs shorter parking contract extension; capital audit and housing bonds head to council
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Public Works and Transportation Committee Tuesday, October 13
8 items
Minutes of the September 22, 2026 committee meeting Item 1
Approval of the draft minutes from the committee's September 22, 2026 meeting. Routine. 00:04:19
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve the draft minutes as is. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:04:35Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Ken Houston, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
Schedule of pending committee items Item 2
The committee's list of items scheduled for future meetings. The clerk corrected it: the 2025 Safe Oakland Streets annual informational report had been placed on the October 27 Public Works agenda by mistake and is scheduled instead for the October 27 Public Safety Committee. 00:04:35
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7), to approve the pending list as amended. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:08:22Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Ken Houston. From the clerk's record
- The city clerk announced that the 2025 Safe Oakland Streets annual report was mistakenly listed for this committee's October 27 meeting and belongs to the October 27 Public Safety Committee 00:04:35
East 12th Street Bikeway construction contract Item 3
Biking and walkingContracts and purchasingStreet safety
A $5,055,898 construction contract to McGuire and Hester, the lowest responsible and responsive bidder, for the East 12th Street Bikeway (project 1003980), plus authority for the City Administrator to approve change orders up to 25% of the contract amount. Staff said the project closes a one-mile gap in the bike network between International Boulevard at 54th Avenue and the Fruitvale BART station, with protected bike lanes, paving, new ADA curb ramps, signal work, and traffic calming such as traffic circles and speed bumps. 00:08:22
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve and forward to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:22:37Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the project closes a one-mile gap in the bikeway network, routing cyclists off International Boulevard at 54th Avenue to Fruitvale BART via East 12th Street 00:10:06
- City staff listed the improvements, including protected bike lanes, restriping, paving, ADA curb ramps, wayfinding, signal upgrades and traffic calming 00:10:06
- City staff said four bids came in and McGuire and Hester was the lowest responsible and responsive bidder 00:10:06
- City staff said the project is funded by an Alameda County Transportation Commission grant, Measure U and gas tax revenue 00:11:09
- City staff said staff do not expect to use the full 25% change order authority, which helps keep schedule and control costs 00:11:09
- A speaker asked for the project timeline 00:12:13
- City staff said construction would likely start in spring 2027, after contracting, and take about a year 00:12:44
- A councilmember asked staff to explain the contract's local business participation and credited percentages 00:13:02
- A councilmember asked staff to track and report back on the money that small local businesses receive under the contract 00:14:41
- A councilmember said the extra cost compared with a lower, non-compliant bid was worth it for local small businesses 00:15:10
- City staff said change orders are evaluated case by case and typically go to the same subcontractor when existing work must be redone 00:19:35
- City staff clarified that the whole project, including change orders, must meet the minimum small and local business requirements 00:20:28
- A speaker said the city has paperwork certifying payments to small local businesses but no oversight function yet, and is piloting tracking software with the housing department 00:20:59
- A councilmember asked that results of the payment tracking come back to the council 00:22:00
Amending state housing grant resolution for Residences at Liberation Park Item 4
Affordable housingFederal and state funding
Amends Resolution No. 91091 C.M.S., which accepted state Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program (Round 8, 2024-2025) loan and grant funds for the Residences at Liberation Park project, in an amount not to exceed $44,661,404. Staff described it as a technical change to who receives part of the grant money, needed because the state won't release the funds otherwise. 00:22:37
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve and forward to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:27:17Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff described the amendment as technical, changing who receives a portion of the grant funds while the total award, city funding and projects stay the same 00:23:21
- City staff said the state requires the amendment before releasing funds because the original resolution named specific payees 00:23:21
Construction management contract for MLK Jr. Way streetscape Item 5
Streets and public worksBiking and walkingPublic employees
A $4,000,000 professional services agreement with Azad Engineering PC to manage construction of the Martin Luther King Jr. Way Streetscape Improvements Project (number 1008516), which staff said includes pedestrian crossings, lighting, street trees, seating, a two-way cycle track and upgraded signals on MLK Way between 2nd and 14th Streets. Staff said the city is hiring outside help because its construction management team has a very high vacancy rate. 00:34:19
- Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve and forward to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:34:19Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Noel Gallo, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff described the streetscape project's improvements on MLK Way between 2nd and 14th Streets 00:27:49
- City staff said Azad is an Oakland-certified small local business that proposed to do most of the work itself 00:28:49
- City staff said the contract is fully funded by state and local grants 00:28:49
- City staff said the city issued a request for proposals on July 17, received two proposals in mid-August, and Azad scored highest 00:28:49
- A councilmember said it is frustrating to contract the work out and asked why the city can't do it in house 00:29:36
- A speaker said the construction management team for large streetscape projects has an 80% vacancy rate and grant deadlines require consultants 00:29:50
- A councilmember said the general goal is to bring such work in house as much as possible 00:30:11
Ready-mix concrete purchases, with sanctuary and border wall waivers Item 6
Contracts and purchasingStreets and public worksSeniors and disability
Authorizes buying ready-mix concrete as needed for four years from CalPortland, CEMEX, and one more eligible supplier, up to $400,000 per supplier per year, $1,200,000 a year in total and $4,800,000 over four years (agenda); pays up to $70,000 in unpaid CalPortland invoices; waives further competitive bidding; and waives the city's border wall and sanctuary city contracting prohibitions for these suppliers. Staff said the two suppliers in Oakland refused to sign the city's certifications, and without concrete deliveries the in-house ADA curb ramp program is suspended, which affects the city's consent decree obligations. 00:34:56
▶ Hear it Why have sanctuary rules if the city keeps waiving them? · 0:52
- Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee), to approve and forward to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:49:32Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Ken Houston, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the resolution also covers up to $70,000 for concrete delivered after the prior purchase authority expired 00:36:44
- City staff said the Oakland market has only two to three providers and a 2025 request for quotes drew none 00:36:44
- City staff said CalPortland and CEMEX accepted the city's terms, including prevailing wage, but declined the certifications barring ICE detention services and border wall work 00:37:47
- City staff said the municipal code lets the council waive the two requirements when no reasonable alternatives exist, which staff believe is the case 00:37:47
- City staff said crews now mix concrete by hand and the in-house ADA curb ramp program is suspended, affecting the capital program and consent decree obligations 00:38:48
- A councilmember asked what is being done to bring on a third supplier and how many of the suppliers' workers live in Oakland 00:39:58
- City staff said Sierra Pacific had no plans to reopen its Wood Street plant, and the third-supplier slot keeps the option open 00:40:26
- City staff said CalPortland could not estimate its Oakland employees, and two limited-duration city concrete finishers would likely be let go in February without concrete 00:41:27
- A councilmember requested the concrete mix designs for curb and gutter work to see whether a small local company could supply it 00:41:53
- A councilmember asked why the city adopts sanctuary city and border wall rules if it waives them so often 00:42:25
- A councilmember said a large contracting reform package being prepared would address those questions 00:42:25
- A speaker said the city has one concrete mixing truck 00:48:17
- City staff said the equipment backlog exceeds $50 million, so upgrading the fleet will take a long time 00:48:38
City Auditor's audit of capital project financial management Item 7
AuditsStreets and public worksContracts and purchasing
An informational report from the City Auditor on how the city manages money for capital projects such as roads, parks and buildings, covering July 2022 through June 2025, when the city spent about $300 million on them. Findings included an unadopted construction management manual, inconsistent approvals of change orders, about $35,000 in overpayments, slow invoice payments that cost $66,000 in interest on one project, weak oversight of Measure KK and Measure U bond funds, and no long-term capital plan. Management agreed or partly agreed with all 17 recommendations. 00:49:32
▶ Hear it Should big change orders come back to council for review? · 0:38
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7), to forward the report to the October 20 City Council agenda on non-consent for a presentation. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 01:28:11Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Ken Houston. From the clerk's record
- A speaker said the audit was requested by the transportation director and covers fiscal years 2023 through 2025 00:50:36
- A speaker said the city spent about $300 million on capital projects over the three fiscal years, with bond measures the largest funding source 00:53:47
- A speaker said change orders took an average of 79 days and a median of 35 days to issue, versus the manual's two weeks 00:54:48
- A speaker said neither Public Works nor Transportation has formally adopted the construction management manual 00:55:52
- A speaker said change orders on a paving project raised its cost by over 25% without council approval 00:57:55
- A speaker said $105 million, or 41% of contracted capital spending, went to on-call contracts with no guidance on their use or extensions 00:59:02
- A speaker said staff often did not follow the manual, including 34 of 65 sampled orders to proceed 01:00:04
- A speaker said vacancies have been persistently high, with about half of construction management engineer positions vacant 01:01:06
- A speaker said project information is scattered across several systems with no central project management system 01:02:15
- A speaker said the city overpaid about $35,000 on seven of 46 projects reviewed, mostly from misapplied markup rates 01:03:19
- A speaker said invoices took an average of 47 days to pay, though local primes must be paid within 20 days 01:05:21
- A speaker said late payments on one project cost the city $66,000 in interest 01:06:27
- A speaker said the city has not adequately overseen Measure KK and Measure U bond funds or done the required annual audits of them 01:07:31
- A speaker said projects sometimes go to bid before designs are complete because of funding deadlines, and five of 92 change orders could have been avoided 01:08:40
- A speaker recommended a 10-year capital improvement plan and at least annual progress reports to the council 01:10:35
- City staff said management agreed or partly agreed with all 17 recommendations and has an implementation plan with target dates 01:12:13
- City staff said seven recommendations will be addressed by updating the construction management manual by February 2027 01:13:13
- City staff said some fixes are done already, including updated payment forms 01:13:13
- A councilmember asked why capital projects are paid late so often, citing a Finance Committee report of about 55% on time versus 90% for other work 01:15:04
- City staff said bond-funded payments require an extra independent Treasury Bureau check, which lengthens the process 01:15:35
- City staff said internal payment timelines might be adjusted once processes improve 01:16:42
- A councilmember asked whether primes could be required to document payments to subcontractors without undue burden 01:17:32
- A speaker said an invoice exhibit lists subcontractor payments, and the city is looking at amending its prime contracts to strengthen requirements 01:18:16
- A councilmember called for one easily accessible place showing the status of each capital project 01:19:10
- A councilmember asked why the city does not use design-build contracts, arguing they save money and reduce change orders 01:20:08
- A speaker said Public Works is open to design-build, especially for facilities like fire stations and recreation centers, but it must be chosen at a project's start 01:21:07
- A speaker warned that bringing every change order to committee would slow projects considerably 01:22:56
- A councilmember suggested change orders above a dollar threshold, such as $200,000, come back to the council 01:23:09
EPA grant for PCB cleanup in Arroyo Viejo Creek Item 8
PollutionFederal and state funding
Accepts up to $3,000,000 from the U.S. EPA San Francisco Bay Program for removing legacy PCB contamination in Arroyo Viejo Creek in East Oakland. Staff said a 2022 regional water board cleanup order makes the city and Union Pacific Railroad jointly responsible, they plan to split costs evenly, and the grant cuts into a city share that would otherwise be about $4 million of an estimated $8 million maximum. 01:28:11
- Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) moved, seconded by Noel Gallo (Councilmember, District 5; President Pro Tempore), to approve and forward to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 01:33:33Ayes: Ken Houston, Zac Unger, Noel Gallo. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Zac Unger, seconded by Noel Gallo. From the clerk's record
- A speaker said the grant supports the city's obligations under a 2022 regional water board cleanup order 01:29:07
- A speaker said a cost-sharing agreement being developed with Union Pacific would split costs evenly 01:29:07
- A speaker said the city would otherwise bear about $4 million of an estimated maximum of about $8 million 01:30:14
- A speaker told a public commenter that public comment is not a back-and-forth 01:31:34
- A speaker said the grant requires a 25% match and put it at $1 million, though 25% of $3 million is $750,000 and the agenda doesn't state the match, so the amount is unclear; said the match would come from a Monsanto settlement and the city facilities fund 01:32:36
Public comment
- The same two residents spoke on most items. A third person signed up for every item but never appeared in the room or on Zoom.
- Pending list (1 speaker): asked how parking at the ice center works, how protected bike lanes get swept, whether protected lanes are placed fairly in East and West Oakland, and raised lawsuits over uneven sidewalks.
- East 12th Street Bikeway (2 speakers): one, who rides the route, supported it and said cars often parked in the painted lane; the other asked about limits on change orders, construction impacts, who will work on the job, racial equity in contracting and hiring, and stalled bike lanes on Bancroft.
- Liberation Park grant (1 speaker, 1 passed): argued the amounts going to Black community groups are too small to counter Black displacement, and criticized the race equity statement.
- MLK Way contract (2 speakers): one asked how the project would improve air quality, wanted block-by-block detail, said streetlights elsewhere were installed but never turned on, and asked about racial equity in hiring; the other supported it as a safety project and said the city has one street sweeper that fits protected bike lanes, plus ambassadors who sweep them.
- Ready-mix concrete (2 speakers): one criticized the city's sanctuary policy and its effect on Black residents; the other supported the contract and spoke about the ADA sidewalk consent decree and sidewalks strong enough for fire trucks.
- Capital audit (2 speakers): one praised the audit, raised departments bringing urgent contracts to the council too late, and backed coming contracting reforms; the other said the city had not answered the findings on vacancies and bond oversight, and argued design-build projects can still go over cost.
- Arroyo Viejo grant (1 speaker): pressed staff on whether the grant requires a 25% local match, which staff then answered.
- Open forum (1 speaker): spoke about city labor negotiations and argued pay raises are unfair when most city employees don't live in Oakland.
What's next
- Items 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8 go to the October 20 City Council agenda on consent.
- The capital audit (item 7) goes to the October 20 City Council agenda on non-consent, with a presentation by Michael Houston (City Auditor).
- The 2025 Safe Oakland Streets annual report is scheduled for the October 27 Public Safety Committee, not this committee.
- Staff said they would report back on tracking payments to small local businesses under the East 12th Street contract, and a councilmember asked for those results to come to the council.
- Transportation staff were asked to provide the curb and gutter concrete mix designs to a councilmember.
- A contracting reform package mentioned under a councilmember's label (see uncertainties) is described as nearly done.
- Finance staff said the construction management manual will be updated by February 2027, guidance on on-call contracts will go to the City Administrator for approval, and this committee will hear future updates on the sanitary sewer and storm drain master plans.
- Public Works (a speaker) agreed to discuss with a councilmember a dollar threshold for bringing change orders back to the council, and to flag projects suited to design-build.
- The auditor's office was asked to send its slides to a councilmember's office; staff said the slides are not on Legistar.
- Two limited-duration city concrete finisher positions expire in February and would likely end if concrete can't be bought.
Write to the Public Works and Transportation Committee before its next meeting: its comment form