· 4 items
Finance and Management Committee, Tuesday, October 13
On the episode: Committee backs shorter parking contract extension; capital audit and housing bonds head to council
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Finance and Management Committee Tuesday, October 13
4 items
Approval of draft minutes from September 22, 2026 Item 1
Routine approval of the committee's draft minutes from its September 22, 2026 meeting. 00:01:38
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved and Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) seconded approval of the draft minutes from the committee meeting of September 22, 2026. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:02:03Ayes: Rowena Brown, Zac Unger, Janani Ramachandran. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
Schedule of outstanding committee items Item 2
The committee's list of pending items and when they are scheduled to come back. A public speaker said the committee had not received a report on the City Administrator's spending under the $250,000 authority since 2023; staff said that report is scheduled for the committee's October 27 meeting. 00:02:03
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved and Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) seconded accepting the schedule of outstanding committee items as is. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:05:44Ayes: Rowena Brown, Zac Unger, Janani Ramachandran. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember asked whether a report comes to the committee on City Administrator spending that stays under the $250,000 limit and does not go to the council 00:05:02
- A speaker said that report is scheduled for the October 27 committee meeting 00:05:15
- City staff added that the report will cover fiscal years 2023-24, 2024-25 and 2025-26 00:05:24
Mythics payroll-system support contract extension Item 3
Government technologyPay and pensions
A resolution extending the city's agreement with Mythics, LLC (d/b/a Mythics VIII, LLC) to November 30, 2028 and raising it from $249,850 to a maximum of $1,250,000. Finance staff said the contractor programs the city's Oracle payroll system, which in-house staff could no longer do after retirements, and that the work is needed to keep payroll stable, put new labor-contract terms in place, and meet changing tax law, including federal rules on overtime for W-2s. Added to the agenda under Rule 28. 00:05:44
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) moved and Zac Unger (Councilmember, District 1; Chair, Public Works and Transportation Committee) seconded approving the staff recommendation and forwarding it to the October 20, 2026 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:23:13Ayes: Rowena Brown, Zac Unger, Janani Ramachandran. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Rowena Brown, seconded by Zac Unger. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the extension is critical for payroll stability, compliance with changing legislation, and keeping the Oracle system working 00:06:33
- A councilmember asked why the contract amount is increasing 00:07:19
- City staff explained that staff who knew the system had retired, no one in house could program a new alternative work schedule from a union agreement without breaking the system, and the consultant took six months and used nearly all the money 00:07:28
- A councilmember asked how the contract would help prevent overpayments like those tied to FLSA compliance issues raised in the auditor's report 00:08:17
- City staff said the consultant is fixing and documenting the old code and training current staff, with the hope of making the system more automated and robust 00:08:35
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) asked whether the work would help with overtime calculations 00:09:41
- City staff said the first priority is stabilizing the system and putting in new contract changes, such as new CalPERS and medical contributions under the OPMA labor contract, before eventually adding rules to automate overtime 00:10:15
- City staff said the first year of added money is for compliance, including W-2 requirements and labor agreement changes, with system improvements to follow 00:11:18
- City staff said the contract mainly supports the existing Oracle setup so it does not break, and that a fully integrated system would require reimplementing the city's ERP 00:12:28
- City staff said a key need is capturing the federal tax exemption for overtime on employees' W-2s, noting the city's labor-contract definition of overtime differs from the federal one 00:13:35
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) noted the council had approved a system to support police overtime calculation and flagged that the systems need to communicate with each other 00:14:54
- City staff said they doubt the current Oracle R12 system can support a Telestaff integration for police without breaking, and that a proper integration likely belongs in a next-generation ERP 00:15:18
- City staff explained that Telestaff must first be configured to track police scheduling accurately, which is an IT project with the police department, before it could feed payroll 00:17:03
- Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) said her reading of the report is that $250,000 is already allocated from Fund 4510, with the rest coming from that fund in the next budget cycle 00:22:29
- City staff confirmed that and said this is spending authority, so the money will not be spent if it is not needed 00:22:44
Parking citation system contract with Modaxo, shortened Item 4
ParkingContracts and purchasingSurveillance technology
Staff asked to amend the city's agreement with Modaxo Traffic Management Inc. for parking citation software, hardware and services, extending it to March 31, 2028 for up to $5,279,143, including up to $1,347,328 in outstanding invoices, and to waive competitive bidding (agenda). The contract ran out in April 2026, and the vendor has kept providing services since. Staff said the platform handles citation processing, permits, payments, customer portals, collections, and handheld and license plate recognition devices, and supports about $29.7 million in budgeted parking revenue this fiscal year. Members objected to a 30% collection fee that staff said is added to tickets at day 61. The committee shortened the extension to June 30, 2027 on the same terms and approved paying the outstanding invoices. It also told staff to come back as soon as possible with other vendor options, including privacy protections for license plate data. Added to the agenda under Rule 28. 00:23:13
- Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved and Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee) seconded approving the staff recommendation as amended: the agreement is extended only to June 30, 2027 under the same terms, the outstanding invoices are paid, and staff is directed to return to council as soon as possible with other vendor options, including privacy protections on data collection. Forwarded to the October 20, 2026 City Council agenda on consent. Result: passed, 3-0, one excused. 00:53:46Ayes: Rowena Brown, Zac Unger, Janani Ramachandran. Absent: Charlene Wang. Moved by Janani Ramachandran, seconded by Rowena Brown. From the clerk's record
- A speaker presented the request as the fourth and final amendment to the agreement with Modaxo, extending it 24 months from April 2026 through March 2028 00:24:23
- A speaker said the system supports collection of about $29.7 million in budgeted parking revenue for the current fiscal year 00:25:25
- A speaker said the agreement expired in April 2026, and that after the program moved from the Department of Transportation to Finance, Finance reviewed its contracts and practices 00:25:25
- A speaker said negotiations produced an agreement that collection fees will not apply to citations under the state-mandated indigent payment plan 00:26:26
- A speaker described the extension as a temporary bridge to allow a competitive procurement for a long-term parking management system 00:26:26
- A speaker said staff is also exploring gated entry and exit at city-owned parking garages 00:27:27
- A councilmember said they were very concerned that 30% goes to a company that does not do the collections, called it a blow to public trust, and said they could not support extending the contract 00:28:28
- A councilmember asked why the contract came to Finance so many months after it expired 00:29:29
- A speaker said no one from the Department of Transportation was present to explain, that Finance aims to bring the contract into compliance and pay the vendor for services since April, and that procurement staff are short-handed 00:29:48
- A councilmember asked why a private company gets 30% for collections work done by the DMV, the city, or state programs 00:31:12
- A speaker said the fee is part of the vendor's pay for specialized services and depends on collecting delinquent balances, and that the DMV and Franchise Tax Board portions are under negotiation 00:31:34
- City staff pointed to a cost breakdown on page four of the report showing options with and without the special collection services 00:32:11
- A councilmember said the two options differ by only about $300,000 and that dropping the service would shift the cost from ticket payers to the city, so neither was acceptable 00:32:23
- A councilmember noted six months of the 24 had already passed and asked whether staff needs the remaining 18 months for a full RFP 00:32:54
- A speaker said a request for information goes out this month and a request for proposals in November 00:33:24
- A speaker said switching vendors would require moving terabytes of historical data, and recommended the full term 00:34:24
- A councilmember said the problem is the contract terms, not the vendor, and asked whether a shorter term would be workable 00:34:55
- A speaker said a shorter term would put staff in a crunch 00:35:38
- City staff said a shorter timeline could mean staff returns with another extension 00:35:54
- A councilmember raised privacy concerns about the license plate data the company collects and noted that Los Angeles's transportation department added privacy protections 00:36:25
- A councilmember said the outstanding invoices must be paid, the city could get better terms, and she wanted to know what other vendors are available 00:37:28
- A councilmember asked whether a 30% fee is typical for this kind of company 00:37:52
- A speaker said such fees typically range from 20 to 30 percent in the industry 00:38:35
- City staff said the 30% rate is not unusual, but the arrangement of charging it on money sent through the DMV or Franchise Tax Board is something they had not seen before 00:38:47
- A speaker explained the 30% is added to a ticket on day 61, an internal business decision inherited from the Department of Transportation that will be revisited with an equity lens in the new RFP 00:39:43
- A councilmember moved to extend the contract only to the end of this fiscal year, June 30, and to have staff return with an alternative 00:42:34
- City staff said staff can bring back options under a shorter term, that the committee would hear back in December or January, and that this may affect the procurement process 00:43:15
- City staff said the department is working citywide to stop paying contracts in arrears and will not pay any contract until the council authorizes it 00:45:23
- City staff recommended that a short extension keep the current collection process, including the special collection services, so staff can focus on the new procurement 00:46:16
- A councilmember restated the motion: extend to June 30, 2027 on the same terms, with direction to return quickly with other options and to include privacy protections on license plate reader data 00:48:05
Public comment
- Item 2: one speaker said the committee had not received the required report on the City Administrator's spending authority of up to $250,000 since 2023, criticized approval of about $12,000 in Measure Z funds for police travel to Washington, D.C., and asked for a review of the fiscal impact of Oakland's sanctuary city status. A second person signed up but was not in the Zoom queue.
- Item 3 (Mythics): one speaker questioned the fiscal impact statement saying the item depends on funds being available, and criticized approving an agreement that started July 1, 2026 after the fact, comparing it to a police labor agreement approved late the week before. A second person signed up but was not in the queue.
- Item 4 (parking citation contract): three speakers. One resident backed a minimal extension and said parking policy is tied to traffic safety and demand-based parking, and asked why the Department of Transportation was absent. A representative of the vendor thanked the city and offered to answer questions. Another speaker criticized using Rule 28 to skip the Rules Committee, asked whether the outstanding invoices violate the city's prompt payment policy, and noted the report says a 2023 extension was with a different company, Conduent, without explaining when the contractor changed.
- Open forum: two speakers. One asked about the ABC Securities contract, which the speaker said expired September 30, and raised the racial demographics of the contractor's security staff. The other raised police overtime and criticized a police collision report on an October 9 fatal crash on Foothill Boulevard as poorly written.
What's next
- Items 3 (Mythics extension) and 4 (Modaxo parking citation contract, as amended) were forwarded to the October 20, 2026 City Council agenda on consent.
- The report on City Administrator spending under the $250,000 authority is scheduled for the committee's October 27 meeting and will cover fiscal years 2023-24 through 2025-26, according to staff.
- Staff said it will return in December or January with options for the parking citation contract after June 30, 2027, such as better terms with the current vendor or a transition to a new one.
- Staff said a request for information on parking management goes out in October and a request for proposals is planned for November.
- A committee member asked whether the Telestaff work for police would come to this committee.
Write to the Finance and Management Committee before its next meeting: its comment form